TL;DR
- Proton VPN wins on privacy, Swiss jurisdiction and its free plan, while Private Internet Access wins on price, unlimited devices and torrenting.
- My top pick over both is Surfshark One at $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan with 3 extra months free, and it kept 96% of my speed.
- Proton VPN costs $2.99/mo on the 2-year plan and kept 92% of my speed, but it limits you to 10 devices.
- Private Internet Access costs $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan, but it kept only 84% of my speed and is based in the US.
- Choose Proton VPN for privacy, Private Internet Access for budget and P2P, or Surfshark One for the best all-round deal.
This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase a VPN through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences our reviews or rankings.
Surfshark One
Surfshark One is the fastest VPN I tested, with unlimited devices and a full security bundle from $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan. It beats both Proton VPN and PIA on speed and all-round value.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- CleanWeb
- RAM-only servers
- Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Fastest in my tests at 96% speed retention
- Unlimited devices
- Antivirus and Alert included
- RAM-only servers
- Netherlands base (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price
Proton VPN and Private Internet Access (PIA) are two of the most trusted names in the VPN market, but they suit very different people. I tested both to see which one deserves your money in 2026.
The short version: Proton VPN is the privacy pick, and PIA is the budget and torrenting pick. Proton gives you Swiss jurisdiction and a free plan, while PIA gives you unlimited devices at about $2 a month.
I also tested both against Surfshark One, my number one VPN. It kept more of my speed than either rival, so you will see it in this comparison too.
Deals verified November 20, 2026
Proton VPN vs PIA: Quick Ranking
Here is how the three VPNs rank after my testing, with the best current deals underneath.
- 1. Surfshark One: best overall, fastest, best bundle, from $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan.
- 2. Proton VPN: best for privacy, from $2.99/mo on the 2-year plan.
- 3. Private Internet Access: best for unlimited devices and torrenting, from $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan.
Surfshark One
The fastest VPN I tested, with unlimited devices and a full security bundle.
- Unlimited devices
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- RAM-only servers
Proton VPN
Swiss, open-source VPN with Secure Core, Stealth and the best free plan around.
- 20000+ servers
- Secure Core
- NetShield
- Free plan
- 10 devices
Private Internet Access
Budget VPN with unlimited devices, port forwarding and open-source apps.
- Unlimited devices
- Port forwarding
- Multi-hop
- MACE blocker
- All 50 US states
Proton VPN vs PIA: Comparison Table
This table puts the key specs side by side. Speed is the share of my no-VPN download speed that each VPN kept during my tests.
| VPN | Best for | Price | Speed retention | Devices | Servers | Based in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Surfshark One | Best overall | $2.49/mo on 2 years ($67.23 for 27 months) | 96% | Unlimited | 4500+ in 100+ countries | Netherlands |
| Proton VPN | Privacy | $2.99/mo on 2 years ($71.76 for 24 months) | 92% | 10 | 20000+ in 140+ countries | Switzerland |
| Private Internet Access | Unlimited devices | $2.03/mo on 3 years ($79 for 39 months) | 84% | Unlimited | Undisclosed, 170+ locations in 104 countries | United States |
Proton VPN leads on country coverage, speed and privacy architecture. PIA leads on price and device count, and it has servers in all 50 US states.
How I Tested Proton VPN and PIA
I compared both services on the same factors I use for every VPN review. I focused on the points that actually change the buying decision.
- Price on the longest plan and on the monthly plan
- Speed retention against my no-VPN baseline
- Jurisdiction, audits and no-logs history
- Server coverage and extra features
- Streaming, torrenting and port forwarding
- Device limits, apps and refund terms
Speed Results: Proton VPN vs PIA
Surfshark One kept 96% of my baseline speed, Proton VPN kept 92% and PIA kept 84%. That means Proton VPN lost about 8% and PIA lost about 16%.
| VPN | Speed retention | Speed rank |
|---|---|---|
| Surfshark One | 96% | 1st |
| Proton VPN | 92% | 2nd |
| Private Internet Access | 84% | 3rd |
In daily use, both Proton VPN and PIA are fast enough for HD and 4K streaming and big downloads. The gap is easier to notice on gigabit connections and long distance servers.
If PIA feels slow, switch it to WireGuard in the app settings, because OpenVPN is usually the slower option.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
1. Surfshark One
Surfshark One is the VPN I rank above both Proton VPN and PIA. If I had to choose one provider today, this is the one I would buy.
Surfshark One
Surfshark One is the fastest VPN I tested, with unlimited devices and a full security bundle from $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan. It beats both Proton VPN and PIA on speed and all-round value.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- CleanWeb
- RAM-only servers
- Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Fastest in my tests at 96% speed retention
- Unlimited devices
- Antivirus and Alert included
- RAM-only servers
- Netherlands base (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price
What You Get With Surfshark One
- Unlimited devices on one account
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries, all RAM-only
- Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID and scam protection
- CleanWeb ad and tracker blocking
- NoBorders, GPS override and Everlink
- Deloitte-audited no-logs policy
It kept 96% of my baseline speed, which is 4 points more than Proton VPN and 12 points more than PIA. You also get unlimited devices like PIA, which Proton VPN does not offer.
The 2-year plan costs $2.49/mo, billed as $67.23 for 27 months, and it includes 3 extra months free. That is cheaper than Proton VPN at $2.99/mo and close to PIA at $2.03/mo.
Where Surfshark One Falls Short
Surfshark is based in the Netherlands, a Nine Eyes country, so Proton VPN is the safer pick on jurisdiction. It is also owned by Nord Security, and the price rises when you renew.
Those are real trade-offs, but for most people the speed, device limit and bundle outweigh them.
What I liked
- Fastest of the three at 96% speed retention
- Unlimited devices on every plan
- Antivirus, Alert and Alternative ID bundled in
- RAM-only servers and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy
What I didn’t like
- The Netherlands is a Nine Eyes country
- Owned by Nord Security
- Renewal price is higher than the intro deal
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
Read my full Surfshark One review or check the latest Surfshark coupon.
2. Proton VPN
Proton VPN comes from the team behind Proton Mail and is built around privacy first. It is based in Switzerland, its apps are open source, and its no-logs policy has passed five consecutive annual audits.
Proton VPN
Proton VPN is the privacy pick of the two, with Swiss jurisdiction, open-source apps and five consecutive audited no-logs reports. It costs more than PIA on a long plan and caps you at 10 devices.
- 20000+ servers in 140+ countries
- Secure Core
- NetShield
- Stealth protocol
- Port forwarding
- Tor over VPN
- Free plan
- 10 devices
- Swiss jurisdiction
- Open-source apps
- Audited no-logs policy
- Free plan with no data cap
- 10 device limit
- Renews at $83.88/yr
- Slower than Surfshark One
Proton VPN Pricing
- Free plan: $0, unlimited data, 1 device, medium speeds
- 1 month: $9.99
- 1 year: $3.99/mo, billed as $47.88
- 2 years: $2.99/mo, billed as $71.76
Proton renews at $83.88/yr, so the intro price is not what you pay forever. The refund also covers unused time only, so treat the free plan as your real trial.
Privacy and Security Features
- Swiss jurisdiction, outside the Five, Nine and Fourteen Eyes alliances
- Open-source apps and five consecutive annual no-logs audits
- Secure Core routing through privacy-friendly countries
- Stealth protocol to get past VPN blocking
- NetShield ad, tracker and malware blocking
- Tor over VPN and port forwarding on paid plans
Proton VPN kept 92% of my baseline speed, which is 8 points better than PIA. It runs 20000+ servers in 140+ countries, and Proton says they are physical bare-metal servers.
Where Proton VPN Falls Short
The biggest limit is 10 simultaneous devices, where PIA and Surfshark One are unlimited. It also costs more than PIA on a long plan, and the free plan blocks streaming and P2P.
I also dislike the prorated refund, and Proton does not offer Smart DNS for game consoles and older TV boxes.
What I liked
- Swiss jurisdiction and open-source apps
- Five consecutive audited no-logs reports
- Best free VPN plan with no data cap
- Secure Core and Stealth for high-risk users
- 92% speed retention in my tests
What I didn’t like
- Limited to 10 devices
- Renews at $83.88/yr
- Costs more than PIA on a long plan
- Refund is prorated
Proton VPN
Plus · 2-year plan
$2.99/mo
$71.76 upfront for 24 months
Read my full Proton VPN review or see the latest Proton VPN coupon.
Before I move on to PIA, here is a shortcut if you want to compare every VPN I have tested.
Not sure Proton VPN is right for you?
Compare it side by side with other top VPNs in my full ranking, with Surfshark One at number one.
See the best VPNs →3. Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access (PIA) is a veteran VPN with a long privacy record and one of the lowest prices around. It is based in the United States, but it has backed up its no-logs claims in court and through three Deloitte audits.
Private Internet Access
PIA is the budget pick of the two, with unlimited devices, port forwarding and a court-tested no-logs record from $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan. It lost the most speed in my tests and is based in the US.
- 170+ locations in 104 countries
- All 50 US states
- Port forwarding
- Multi-hop
- Shadowsocks
- MACE blocker
- Unlimited devices
- Open-source apps
- Unlimited devices
- Open-source apps
- Port forwarding
- Cheapest of the two
- US base (Five Eyes)
- 84% speed retention
- No free plan
- Best price needs a 3-year plan
PIA Pricing
- 1 month: $11.95
- 3 years: $2.03/mo, billed as $79 for 39 months
- Optional add-ons such as a Dedicated IP
Every plan gets the same features, including unlimited devices. There is no free plan, but you get a 30-day money-back guarantee, and the mobile apps add a 7-day store trial.
Privacy and Security Features
- Open-source apps you can inspect
- Three independent Deloitte no-logs audits, the latest completed in December 2025
- No-logs claims backed up in court
- Multi-hop, Shadowsocks and split tunneling
- MACE blocker for ads, trackers and malware
- Built-in port forwarding
PIA runs 170+ locations across 104 countries and territories, including servers in all 50 US states. It does not publish a server count, though industry estimates put it at 35000+.
It kept 84% of my baseline speed, the lowest of the three. It is still fast, just not the quickest.
Where PIA Falls Short
PIA is based in the US, a Five Eyes country, and it has no Secure Core style protection like Proton VPN. The best price also needs a 3-year commitment.
The settings screen can overwhelm beginners, and port forwarding does not work on its US servers.
What I liked
- Unlimited devices on every plan
- Cheapest long-term price of the two
- Port forwarding built into the app
- Open-source apps and Deloitte audits
What I didn’t like
- US base in a Five Eyes country
- Slowest of the three at 84% retention
- No free plan
- No port forwarding on US servers
Read my full PIA review or see the latest PIA coupon.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Pricing Compared
PIA wins on long-term price, while Proton VPN wins on monthly price and has a free plan. Both back every paid plan with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
| Plan detail | Proton VPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes, unlimited data, 1 device | No |
| Monthly plan | $9.99 | $11.95 |
| Best long-term deal | $2.99/mo on 2 years ($71.76 for 24 months) | $2.03/mo on 3 years ($79 for 39 months) |
| Devices | 10 | Unlimited |
| Renewal | $83.88/yr | Check at checkout |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days, prorated | 30 days |
Watch the renewal price. Intro prices rise when your plan renews, and Proton VPN renews at $83.88/yr. Set a reminder before your plan ends so you are not surprised.
PIA costs $79 up front for 39 months, while Proton VPN costs $71.76 for 24 months. Per month, PIA is about $0.96 cheaper, and you get unlimited devices on top.
If you only need a VPN for a short time, Proton VPN has the cheaper monthly plan at $9.99 versus $11.95. If you have no budget at all, Proton Free is the only one of the two that costs nothing.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Privacy and Jurisdiction
This is the biggest difference between the two. Proton VPN is based in Switzerland, outside the Five, Nine and Fourteen Eyes alliances, and Swiss law does not require it to keep user logs.
PIA is based in the United States, which is a founding Five Eyes country. On paper that is a red flag, but PIA has backed up its no-logs claims in court and through three independent Deloitte audits.
Audits and Transparency
- Proton VPN: five consecutive annual no-logs audits, with full reports published
- PIA: three Deloitte audits, the latest completed in December 2025
- Both: open-source apps that researchers can inspect
Proton VPN takes the privacy crown for me. Its Swiss base and Secure Core design give it an extra layer that PIA does not have.
That said, PIA is trustworthy for everyday privacy. If you are a journalist, activist or work in a high-risk country, choose Proton VPN instead.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Servers and Locations
Proton VPN runs 20000+ servers in 140+ countries, which gives it wider global reach. PIA has 170+ locations across 104 countries and territories, and it does not publish its server count.
- Proton VPN: 140+ countries, Secure Core routes and free servers in a handful of countries
- PIA: 104 countries and territories, servers in all 50 US states and 35 streaming-optimized locations
- Surfshark One: 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
PIA is the better pick if you need a local IP in a specific US state. Proton VPN is the better pick if you want an IP almost anywhere else in the world.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Streaming
Proton VPN includes worldwide streaming support on paid plans, but the free plan does not unblock streaming sites. PIA has dedicated streaming-optimized servers in 35 locations, plus all 50 US states for local content.
I call this one a tie. PIA has the edge for US content and sports blackouts, while Proton VPN has the edge for global libraries.
For TV setups, see my guides to the best VPN for Amazon Prime Video and the best VPN for Firestick.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Torrenting and Port Forwarding
PIA is the better torrenting VPN of the two. It allows P2P across its network and builds port forwarding into the app, which can improve speeds in a torrent swarm.
Proton VPN allows P2P on paid plans and supports port forwarding on Windows, macOS and Linux. It blocks P2P on the free plan.
PIA port forwarding limit. Port forwarding does not work on PIA’s US servers, so connect to a server in another country if you need it.
With unlimited devices, P2P support and easy port forwarding, PIA wins this round.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Censorship and Restricted Countries
Proton VPN is stronger here. Its Stealth protocol helps hide VPN traffic, Secure Core adds extra routing protection, and its 140+ country network includes many hard-to-reach locations.
PIA offers Shadowsocks and has added servers in places like Cuba, Belarus and Myanmar. That helps, but Proton VPN has the stronger anti-censorship toolkit.
VPN laws differ by country, so check your local rules before you connect.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Apps, Devices and Features
PIA lets you protect unlimited devices, while Proton VPN caps you at 10. Both have open-source apps, but Proton VPN feels cleaner, and PIA gives you far more settings to tweak.
| Feature | Proton VPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Simultaneous devices | 10 | Unlimited |
| Open-source apps | Yes | Yes |
| Free plan | Yes | No |
| Multi-hop | Secure Core | Yes |
| Obfuscation | Stealth protocol | Shadowsocks |
| Ad and malware blocker | NetShield | MACE |
| Port forwarding | Windows, macOS, Linux | Yes, not on US servers |
| Tor over VPN | Yes | No |
| Servers in all 50 US states | No | Yes |
If you want a click-and-forget app, Proton VPN is the easier choice. If you like tuning every setting, PIA is the better fit.
Proton VPN vs PIA vs Surfshark One
Both Proton VPN and PIA are strong, but Surfshark One beats them on what most people feel every day. It was faster in my tests, it has unlimited devices, and it adds security tools in one bundle.
- Speed: 96% for Surfshark One, 92% for Proton VPN and 84% for PIA
- Devices: unlimited on Surfshark One and PIA, 10 on Proton VPN
- Price: $2.49/mo for Surfshark One, $2.99/mo for Proton VPN and $2.03/mo for PIA
- Extras: Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID and CleanWeb on Surfshark One
Where Surfshark One loses is jurisdiction, because the Netherlands is a Nine Eyes country. If that matters most, choose Proton VPN. If it does not, Surfshark One is the stronger all-round buy.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
Want the full breakdown? Read my Surfshark One review or the Surfshark vs NordVPN comparison.
Proton VPN vs PIA: Who Wins Each Category?
| Category | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Long-term price | PIA | $2.03/mo on 3 years vs $2.99/mo on 2 years |
| Monthly price | Proton VPN | $9.99 vs $11.95 |
| Free plan | Proton VPN | Unlimited data, no ads, 1 device |
| Speed | Proton VPN | 92% retention vs 84% |
| Privacy and jurisdiction | Proton VPN | Switzerland vs the United States |
| Devices | PIA | Unlimited vs 10 |
| Torrenting | PIA | P2P across the network and easy port forwarding |
| Global coverage | Proton VPN | 140+ countries vs 104 |
| US state coverage | PIA | All 50 US states |
| Censorship tools | Proton VPN | Stealth and Secure Core |
| Streaming | Tie | PIA for US content, Proton VPN for global libraries |
Which VPN Should You Choose?
Use these four steps to decide quickly between Proton VPN and PIA.
Count your devices
If you need more than 10 devices, PIA or Surfshark One is the better fit.
Set your budget
For the lowest price, PIA on the 3-year plan costs $2.03/mo. For no cost at all, use Proton Free.
Decide how much privacy you need
For maximum privacy and Swiss jurisdiction, choose Proton VPN.
Test it risk free
Every paid plan has a 30-day money-back guarantee, so you can test your pick and switch if needed.
Choose Proton VPN If
- Privacy and jurisdiction are your top priority
- You want a free VPN with no data cap
- You need Secure Core or Stealth for a restrictive country
- You want servers in 140+ countries
Choose PIA If
- You want the lowest long-term price of the two
- You have many devices to cover
- You torrent and want built-in port forwarding
- You need a server in a specific US state
Choose Surfshark One If
- You want the fastest VPN I tested at 96% retention
- You want unlimited devices and a security bundle
- You want a price of $2.49/mo with 3 months free
- You can accept a Netherlands base
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Proton VPN better than PIA?
Proton VPN is better for privacy, speed and its free plan. PIA is better for price, unlimited devices and torrenting. For most people, Surfshark One is the stronger all-round pick over both.
Is PIA safe even though it is based in the US?
Yes, in my view. PIA has backed up its no-logs claims in court and through three Deloitte audits. If you need protection from state-level surveillance, Proton VPN is the safer choice.
Which is cheaper, Proton VPN or PIA?
PIA is cheaper on its 3-year plan at $2.03/mo, versus $2.99/mo for Proton VPN on 2 years. Proton VPN is cheaper month to month at $9.99 versus $11.95.
Which is faster, Proton VPN or PIA?
Proton VPN. It kept 92% of my baseline speed, while PIA kept 84%. Surfshark One was faster than both at 96%.
Which is better for torrenting?
PIA is the better torrenting VPN. It allows P2P across its network and has built-in port forwarding, though not on US servers. Proton VPN allows P2P on paid plans only.
Does Proton VPN or PIA have a free plan?
Proton VPN has a free plan with unlimited data and 1 device. PIA has no free plan, but it offers a 30-day money-back guarantee and a 7-day trial on the mobile apps.
How many devices can I use?
Proton VPN allows 10 devices on a paid plan. PIA allows unlimited devices, and so does Surfshark One.
Which is better for streaming?
I call it a tie. PIA has streaming-optimized servers in 35 locations and covers all 50 US states, while Proton VPN’s paid plans suit global libraries.
Do both support port forwarding?
Yes. PIA supports it in the app but not on US servers. Proton VPN supports it on paid plans for Windows, macOS and Linux.
Which VPN do you rank above both?
Surfshark One. It is the fastest VPN I tested at 96% retention, has unlimited devices and costs $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan with 3 extra months free.
Final Verdict: Proton VPN vs PIA
Proton VPN and PIA are both safe, audited and worth considering, but they win different fights. Proton VPN wins on privacy, speed and its free plan, while PIA wins on price, device limit and torrenting.
If you want the best overall VPN, I rank Surfshark One first. It was the fastest in my tests at 96%, includes unlimited devices and costs $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan.
My simple rule: buy Proton VPN for privacy, PIA for budget and P2P, and Surfshark One if you want the best deal with the fewest compromises.
Surfshark One
A fast, feature-packed VPN bundle with unlimited devices, antivirus, breach alerts and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- CleanWeb
- RAM-only servers
- Deloitte-audited no-logs







