TL;DR
- In my tests VeePN edges out Private Internet Access on price and speed, but the right pick depends on how many devices you have.
- My top pick over both is Surfshark One at $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan with 88% off and 3 months free, though renewals cost more.
- VeePN Pro costs $2.40/mo on the 2-year plan for 10 devices, but it has no full independent no-logs audit.
- Private Internet Access costs $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan with unlimited devices, but it is US-based and owned by Kape Technologies.
This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase a VPN through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences our reviews or rankings.
Surfshark One
Surfshark One beats both VeePN and Private Internet Access in my tests. It has unlimited devices, the fastest speeds I measured and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- RAM-only servers
- Fastest in my tests
- Unlimited devices
- Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Antivirus and Alert included
- Netherlands base (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price
I spent months running Private Internet Access (PIA) and VeePN side by side on my desktop, laptops, phones and Fire TV. Both promise a no-logs policy, strong encryption and a very low price, so I wanted to see which one actually holds up.
VeePN ranks higher on my list, mainly because of its lower price and faster speeds. PIA wins on unlimited devices, public audits, open-source apps and torrenting.
If you do not want to compromise, Surfshark One is the VPN I would choose instead. I explain exactly where it fits further down.
Deals verified November 21, 2026. Prices below are the Black Friday and late-2026 promotional rates I saw at checkout. Always confirm the final price before you pay.
PIA vs VeePN: My Ranked List
Here is how the three VPNs in this comparison rank in my testing, from best overall to most specialized.
- 1. Surfshark One: best overall, fastest, best bundle
- 2. VeePN: budget streaming and the lowest entry price
- 3. Private Internet Access: unlimited devices, port forwarding and the strongest audit trail of the two
Surfshark One
Fastest VPN in my tests with unlimited devices, a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy and a full security bundle.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- RAM-only servers
VeePN
Cheap 2-year Pro plan with a security bundle, Panama jurisdiction and a 3-day free trial.
- 2600+ servers
- 196 locations
- Antivirus
- Breach Alert
- Alternative ID
- Shadowsocks
Private Internet Access
Open-source apps, port forwarding and unlimited connections on a low-cost 3-year plan.
- Unlimited devices
- Open-source apps
- Port forwarding
- RAM-only servers
- MACE blocker
PIA vs VeePN Comparison Table
This table puts the facts that matter side by side. I included Surfshark One as a benchmark because it is the VPN I measure everything else against.
| Feature | Surfshark One | VeePN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|---|
| My ranking | 1 | 2 | 3 |
| Best for | Overall, speed, bundle | Budget streaming | Unlimited devices |
| Price on long plan | $2.49/mo (2-year) | $2.40/mo (2-year Pro) | $2.03/mo (3-year) |
| Total upfront | $67.23 for 27 months | $69.72 for 29 months | $79 for 39 months |
| Simultaneous devices | Unlimited | 10 on Pro | Unlimited |
| Servers | 4500+ | 2600+ | 35,000+ reported |
| Countries | 100+ | 148 advertised | 91 |
| Jurisdiction | Netherlands | Panama | United States |
| Independent audit | Deloitte no-logs audit | Cure53 (browser extensions) | Deloitte no-logs audits |
| Open-source apps | No | No | Yes |
| Port forwarding | No | No | Yes |
| Speed retention in my tests | 96% | 88% | 84% |
| Security extras | Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID | Antivirus, Breach Alert, Alternative ID, private AI chat | MACE blocker, dedicated IP add-on |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | 30 days on long plans | 30 days |
How I Tested PIA and VeePN
I tested both VPNs on a 1 Gbps fiber connection in North America. My no-VPN baseline was roughly 940 Mbps down and 920 Mbps up, so I could calculate how much speed each VPN kept.
I used the latest official apps with WireGuard on both services, because it was clearly the fastest protocol. I tested on Windows, macOS and Android, plus a Fire TV Stick for streaming.
- Speed tests with Ookla Speedtest, Cloudflare and large CDN downloads
- DNS, IPv6 and WebRTC leak tests with ipleak.net, browserleaks.com and dnsleaktest.com
- Streaming checks on Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, BBC iPlayer and Amazon Prime Video over three weeks
- Torrenting sessions with legal Linux ISOs and public-domain files
- Live chat and email support questions about server choice, kill switches and refunds
Speed Test Results
Surfshark One kept 96% of my baseline speed, VeePN kept 88% and PIA kept 84%. On nearby servers both VeePN and PIA kept roughly 80 to 90% of my speed.
| VPN | Speed retention | What I noticed |
|---|---|---|
| Surfshark One | 96% | Fastest in my tests and the most consistent |
| VeePN | 88% | Excellent on good nearby servers, but two congested ones dropped to roughly half until I switched |
| Private Internet Access | 84% | Sustained downloads stayed strong for hours, distant servers were usable but slower |
Long distance changed the picture for both. Connecting to Tokyo or Sydney dropped each service into the 30 to 50% range, which still handled 4K streaming and large downloads.
Both passed every DNS, IPv6 and WebRTC leak test with the kill switch on. When I deliberately cut the connection with the kill switch off, both leaked briefly, which is expected behavior.
Neither service throttles bandwidth. If speed is your top priority, though, my Surfshark One review shows why it beat both.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
2. VeePN
VeePN is a Panama-based VPN that sells a cheap long-term plan and bundles extra security tools on its higher tiers. I used it as a budget streaming VPN on secondary devices and during dedicated test weeks.
VeePN
VeePN is a capable budget VPN with good speeds and a useful security bundle on Pro. The missing independent no-logs audit is the main reason I rank it below Surfshark One.
- 2600+ servers
- 196 locations
- Antivirus
- Breach Alert
- Alternative ID
- Shadowsocks
- Low 2-year price
- Panama jurisdiction
- Antivirus and Alternative ID on Pro
- Shadowsocks support
- No full independent no-logs audit
- Smaller network
- 10 device cap on Pro
VeePN Pricing and Plans
VeePN sells three tiers, and the number of devices is the main difference. The Pro plan at $2.40/mo on the 2-year deal costs $69.72 for 29 months, and it is the one I recommend.
Basic starts around $1.99/mo on the 2-year deal but covers only 5 devices and leaves out the security bundle. Max raises the limit to 20 devices at a higher price.
- Basic: 5 devices, core VPN only
- Pro: 10 devices, Antivirus, Breach Alert, Alternative ID and private AI chat
- Max: 20 devices with the same extras as Pro
Long plans come with a 30-day money-back guarantee, and a 3-day free trial is available. Monthly plans are far more expensive per month and have a shorter refund window, so I would skip them.
VeePN Servers and Locations
VeePN advertises 2600+ servers across 196 locations in 148 countries. That headline country count is high, although some independent reviewers count far fewer distinct countries, so check that your destination is covered.
In practice I always found good options in North America and Europe. Quality on distant or less-populated locations was more variable, and I switched servers a few times.
VeePN Privacy, Security and Audits
VeePN is based in Panama, which sits outside the 5, 9 and 14 Eyes alliances. It supports WireGuard, OpenVPN, IKEv2 and Shadowsocks, with a kill switch, DNS and IP leak protection, double VPN, an ad and tracker blocker and split tunneling.
The weak spot is independent proof. Cure53 audited the browser extensions in 2021, but I could not find a public no-logs audit of the core VPN infrastructure like PIA’s Deloitte reports.
VeePN Streaming and Torrenting
VeePN unblocked the major platforms on many servers, but it needed some server hopping. It succeeded on 12 of 18 Netflix US attempts in my tests, and its wider location list helped with a couple of niche regional titles.
Torrenting works, mostly on its P2P-designated servers, and it has the leak protection you need. I had to pick servers manually more often than on PIA.
VeePN Extras and Apps
VeePN has native apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, Android and iOS, plus browser extensions and router support. The interface is cleaner and easier for beginners than PIA’s.
On Pro I used the antivirus with known-safe sample files, and it flagged them correctly without much noise. Shadowsocks also gave it a slight edge in restrictive networks I simulated.
What I liked
- Very low price on the long Pro plan
- Good speeds on nearby servers
- Panama jurisdiction
- Antivirus, Breach Alert and Alternative ID on Pro
- Shadowsocks for restrictive networks
- Clean, beginner-friendly apps
What I didn’t like
- No full independent no-logs audit of the core service
- Device caps of 5, 10 and 20
- Much smaller network than PIA
- More variable performance on distant servers
- Monthly plans are expensive
- Apps are not open source
VeePN
Pro · 2-year plan + 5 months free
$2.40/mo
$69.72 upfront for 29 months
Want the full breakdown or the latest discount? Read my VeePN review or check the VeePN coupon page.
Not sure VeePN or PIA is right for you?
Compare Surfshark One and the other top VPNs side by side in my full comparison guide.
See all VPN comparisons →3. Private Internet Access (PIA)
PIA has been around since 2010 and is now owned by Kape Technologies, the same parent as ExpressVPN and CyberGhost. I used it as my main VPN for several months, and it has the strongest transparency record of the two.
Private Internet Access
PIA is the better choice if you have many devices, torrent or want open-source apps and audit reports. It is slower than VeePN in my tests and the US base will not suit everyone.
- Unlimited devices
- Open-source apps
- Port forwarding
- RAM-only servers
- MACE blocker
- Unlimited devices
- Open-source apps
- Port forwarding
- Deloitte audits and court history
- US jurisdiction (Five Eyes)
- Owned by Kape Technologies
- Slower than VeePN in my tests
PIA Pricing and Plans
PIA has a single feature set on every plan, and only the length changes. The 3-year plan is the best price at $2.03/mo, which works out to $79 for 39 months.
The monthly plan is $11.95, so the discount on the long plan is steep. Every plan includes unlimited simultaneous devices and a 30-day money-back guarantee, but PIA has no free plan.
Renewal prices can differ from the promo rate, so I recommend checking the checkout page before you commit.
PIA Servers and Locations
PIA covers 91 countries, including all 50 US states, and is widely reported to run 35,000+ servers. PIA does not officially confirm that total, so treat it as an estimate.
The dense US coverage helped me with regional content and sports blackouts. The country count is lower than VeePN’s advertised number, but I never ran out of useful locations.
PIA Privacy, Security and Audits
PIA has the stronger proof of the two. Deloitte Audit Romania has audited its no-logs claims several times, including a report in December 2025, and US court cases in 2016 and 2018 showed there was no usable user data to hand over.
The apps are open source and the servers are RAM-only. It supports WireGuard and OpenVPN with AES-128 or AES-256, plus a kill switch, split tunneling, multi-hop, port forwarding and a dedicated IP add-on.
The trade-offs are real. PIA is US-based, which means Five Eyes jurisdiction, and Kape has a history tied to adware under its old Crossrider name.
PIA Streaming and Torrenting
PIA succeeded on 14 of 18 Netflix US attempts in my tests, and switching cities fixed most failures. It is not perfect on every library, so use the refund window to test your own services.
Torrenting is where PIA shines. P2P is allowed on every server and port forwarding gave me noticeably higher peer counts and faster completion times than VeePN on the same files.
PIA Extras and Apps
PIA’s apps are more customizable than VeePN’s, with options for protocol, encryption, ports and MTU. That is great for power users and a little overwhelming for beginners.
MACE blocks ads, trackers and malware at the DNS level, and PIA publishes quarterly transparency reports. Its Linux client and router documentation felt more mature than VeePN’s.
What I liked
- Unlimited devices on every plan
- Multiple Deloitte audits and proven court record
- Open-source apps and RAM-only servers
- Port forwarding on supported servers
- Dense US server coverage
- Highly customizable apps
What I didn’t like
- US jurisdiction (Five Eyes)
- Owned by Kape Technologies
- Slower than VeePN in my tests
- Interface can feel dated for beginners
- Streaming is hit or miss on some libraries
- No free plan
Want more detail? Read my PIA review or the PIA coupon page for the latest discount.
How Surfshark One Compares to VeePN and PIA
Surfshark One is the VPN I would pick over both of them. It kept 96% of my speed, offers unlimited devices like PIA, and has a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy that VeePN cannot match.
It also includes Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID, scam protection and CleanWeb, so you do not need to pay for extras. RAM-only servers and 4500+ servers in 100+ countries round it out.
- Versus VeePN: faster, unlimited devices instead of 10, and a public audit
- Versus PIA: faster and adds a full security bundle, but lacks PIA’s open-source apps and port forwarding
- Cons: Netherlands base (Nine Eyes), owned by Nord Security and a higher renewal price
For a deeper look, read my Surfshark One review or the Surfshark vs NordVPN comparison.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
Pricing Compared
All three VPNs are cheap on long plans, but the long plans are where the savings and the catches sit. Here is the price at the promotional rates I saw in November 2026.
| VPN | Plan | Price per month | Total upfront | Devices |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Surfshark One | 2-year | $2.49/mo | $67.23 for 27 months | Unlimited |
| VeePN Pro | 2-year | $2.40/mo | $69.72 for 29 months | 10 |
| VeePN Basic | 2-year | $1.99/mo | Check at checkout | 5 |
| Private Internet Access | 3-year | $2.03/mo | $79 for 39 months | Unlimited |
| Private Internet Access | Monthly | $11.95/mo | $11.95 | Unlimited |
PIA is the cheapest per month once you account for unlimited devices, but you commit for three years. VeePN Pro costs slightly more per month for a shorter commitment and a bundled antivirus.
Renewals are the catch. Surfshark One renews higher, and I could not lock down VeePN renewal rates, so check the checkout page for all three before you buy.
Device Limits and Household Use
This is the most practical difference between them. PIA gives you unlimited simultaneous devices on every plan, so I protected my Windows desktop, MacBook, two Android phones, iPad and Fire TV Stick without counting.
VeePN caps you at 5 on Basic, 10 on Pro and 20 on Max. For a family you will probably need Pro or Max, which erases part of the price advantage.
Streaming: Which Unblocks More?
Neither VPN unblocks every library every day. Streaming services rotate and block IPs constantly, so expect to switch servers occasionally on both.
- Netflix US: PIA worked on 14 of 18 attempts and VeePN on 12 of 18
- US content and blackouts: PIA’s server coverage in every US state helped
- Niche regional libraries: VeePN’s broader location list helped a few times
- Disney+, Hulu, BBC iPlayer and Prime Video: both worked on many servers with some hopping
If streaming is your main use, use the money-back window to test your own services. My best VPN for Amazon Prime Video guide and best VPN for Firestick guide cover more options.
Torrenting and P2P
PIA is the better torrenting VPN. P2P is allowed on every server, port forwarding is available and the kill switch plus proven no-logs record make it a safe choice.
VeePN supports P2P on its designated servers and has the leak protection you need. The smaller network and the audit gap made me more cautious about using it for heavy torrenting.
Privacy, Jurisdiction and Trust
On paper VeePN has the better jurisdiction because Panama has no mandatory data retention laws like some Western countries. PIA has the better evidence, because its no-logs claims have been audited by Deloitte and tested in US courts.
I weigh demonstrated proof more heavily than a favorable location, since both companies must still follow lawful orders where they operate. If you want both strong proof and a strong feature set, Surfshark One is the stronger overall option.
Which One Should You Choose?
My advice depends on your priorities. Here is how I would decide.
- Choose VeePN if: you need 10 devices or fewer, want the lowest price with a bundled antivirus, or like Panama jurisdiction
- Choose PIA if: you have many devices, torrent regularly or want open-source apps and public audit reports
- Choose Surfshark One if: you want unlimited devices, the fastest speeds and a full security bundle in one subscription
Frequently Asked Questions
Is PIA or VeePN better?
VeePN ranks higher in my testing because of its price and speed, while PIA is better for unlimited devices, torrenting and audit transparency. Surfshark One is my top pick over both.
Which is cheaper, PIA or VeePN?
PIA’s 3-year plan is $2.03/mo and VeePN Pro’s 2-year plan is $2.40/mo, with VeePN Basic around $1.99/mo. PIA includes unlimited devices, while VeePN limits you to 5, 10 or 20.
Which has more servers?
PIA is widely reported to run 35,000+ servers in 91 countries, although it does not officially confirm the total. VeePN advertises 2600+ servers across 196 locations in 148 countries.
Which is faster?
VeePN kept 88% of my baseline speed and PIA kept 84%. Surfshark One was faster than both at 96%.
Which is better for streaming?
Both unblock the major services on many servers. PIA worked on 14 of 18 Netflix US attempts and VeePN on 12 of 18, but results change often, so test during the refund window.
Which is better for torrenting?
PIA, because it allows P2P on every server and supports port forwarding. VeePN works on its P2P servers but needs more manual selection.
How many devices can I connect?
PIA allows unlimited simultaneous devices on every plan. VeePN allows 5 on Basic, 10 on Pro and 20 on Max.
Is VeePN safe and does it keep logs?
VeePN claims a strict no-logs policy and is based in Panama. However, I could not find a public independent no-logs audit of its core infrastructure, only a 2021 Cure53 audit of the browser extensions.
Is PIA safe given its US base and Kape ownership?
PIA’s no-logs claims have been audited by Deloitte and tested in US courts, and its apps are open source. The US jurisdiction and Kape ownership still concern some users, so weigh that against your own threat model.
Do PIA and VeePN have a money-back guarantee?
Both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee on longer plans for new customers. VeePN monthly plans have a shorter refund window, and VeePN also has a 3-day free trial.
Is there a better alternative to PIA and VeePN?
For most people, yes: Surfshark One. It has unlimited devices, the fastest speeds in my tests and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy.
My Final Verdict
VeePN is the better pick if you want a low price, good speeds and a security bundle for up to 10 devices. PIA is the better pick if you want unlimited devices, open-source apps and proven audits, and I would choose it for torrenting.
Neither is my first choice, though. Surfshark One gives you the speed of VeePN, the unlimited devices of PIA and a Deloitte audit, so it is the one I recommend to most readers. Whichever you choose, use the 30-day refund window to test it on your own devices.
Surfshark One
Surfshark One is my top pick over VeePN and PIA. You get unlimited devices, the fastest speeds I measured and a full security bundle for $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- RAM-only servers







