TL;DR
- PrivadoVPN wins on price and its free plan, while Private Internet Access wins on unlimited devices, open-source apps and audited no-logs proof.
- My top pick overall is Surfshark One at $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan with 88% off and 3 months free, and it kept 96% of its speed in my tests.
- PrivadoVPN starts at just $1.11/mo ($30 for 27 months), but it renews at about $3.99/mo and has no published no-logs audit.
- Private Internet Access costs $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan ($79 for 39 months), but it is US-based under Kape and sits inside the Five Eyes alliance.
- Pick PrivadoVPN for 1 to 10 devices on a tight budget, and pick Private Internet Access for big households, port forwarding and audited privacy.
This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase a VPN through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences our reviews or rankings.
Surfshark One
The fastest VPN in my tests with unlimited devices and the best security bundle, from $2.49 per month on the 2-year plan.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- CleanWeb
- Fastest speeds in my tests
- Unlimited devices
- Antivirus and Alert included
- RAM-only servers
- Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Netherlands base (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price
I have been running Private Internet Access (PIA) and PrivadoVPN side by side for months, and the PIA VPN vs PrivadoVPN question is the one I get asked most. Both sit in the budget tier, yet they chase very different buyers.
PrivadoVPN is the cheap, free-plan-friendly option based in Iceland. PIA is the unlimited-device, open-source veteran based in the United States and owned by Kape.
In this guide I compare pricing, speed, privacy proof, server networks, streaming and daily usability with real numbers from my own testing. I also show where Surfshark One beats both, so you can decide with all the facts.
Deals verified November 21, 2026. The prices below match the official buy pages and my own checks this month, but promotions such as Black Friday change quickly.
PIA VPN vs PrivadoVPN: My Ranking
- Surfshark One: best overall, fastest, best bundle.
- PrivadoVPN: best VPN with a free plan and the cheapest paid plans.
- Private Internet Access: best for unlimited devices, open-source apps and audited privacy.
Surfshark One
Fastest VPN in my tests with unlimited devices, antivirus and a full security bundle.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers
- Antivirus
- Alert
- RAM-only servers
PrivadoVPN
Cheapest paid plans plus a free plan with 10 GB per month, based in Iceland.
- Free plan with 10 GB
- 10 connections
- Ad blocker
- Parental controls
- SOCKS5 proxy
Private Internet Access
Unlimited connections, open-source apps, port forwarding and Deloitte-audited no-logs.
- Unlimited devices
- 113 countries
- Open-source apps
- Port forwarding
- Multi-hop
PIA VPN vs PrivadoVPN Comparison Table
Here is the short version before the deep dive. I added Surfshark One as a reference row because it is the VPN I recommend over both.
| VPN | Lowest price | Devices | Jurisdiction | Audited no-logs | Speed retention |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Surfshark One | $2.49/mo on 2-year plan ($67.23 for 27 months) | Unlimited | Netherlands (Nine Eyes) | Yes, Deloitte | 96% |
| PrivadoVPN | $1.11/mo on 2-year plan ($30 for 27 months) | 10 paid, 1 free | Iceland | No published audit | 85% |
| Private Internet Access | $2.03/mo on 3-year plan ($79 for 39 months) | Unlimited | United States (Five Eyes) | Yes, Deloitte plus court cases | 84% |
PrivadoVPN is cheaper upfront, while Private Internet Access is cheaper to keep for years and covers unlimited devices. Neither matches Surfshark One on speed retention in my tests.
Head-to-Head Feature Table
| Feature | PrivadoVPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes, 10 GB per 30 days | No |
| Simultaneous devices | 10 (paid), 1 (free) | Unlimited |
| Server locations | About 49 to 63 countries, about 66 cities | 113 countries and territories |
| No-logs audits | None published | Deloitte in 2022, 2024 and December 2025, plus court cases |
| Jurisdiction | Iceland (outside Eyes alliances) | United States (Five Eyes) |
| Open-source apps | No | Yes |
| Multi-hop | Limited, not emphasized | Yes |
| Port forwarding | No | Yes, on selected servers |
| Dedicated IP | No | Add-on |
| Ad blocker | Yes, on paid plans | MACE |
| Antivirus | Sentry add-on at $1.99/mo | Add-on |
| Parental controls | Yes, on paid plans | No |
| Protocols | WireGuard, OpenVPN and IKEv2 | WireGuard and OpenVPN |
| P2P and torrenting | Allowed | Allowed on most servers |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | 30 days |
| Lowest promo price | $1.11/mo (2-year) | $2.03/mo (3-year) |
Category Winners
- Price: PrivadoVPN wins at $1.11/mo for the first 27 months.
- Long-term cost: PIA wins thanks to its low renewal rate.
- Devices: PIA wins with unlimited connections versus 10 on PrivadoVPN.
- Free plan: PrivadoVPN wins, because PIA has none.
- Privacy proof: PIA wins with Deloitte audits and court cases.
- Jurisdiction: PrivadoVPN wins with Iceland instead of the US.
- Server network: PIA wins with 113 countries and territories.
- Speed retention: effectively tied at 85% versus 84%.
How I Tested PIA and PrivadoVPN
I paid for both services on their long-term plans and used them for months on a 2023 MacBook Pro, a phone and a Linux machine. I wanted daily-use results rather than a one-afternoon review.
Speed tests
Every test used a wired 1 Gbps connection, Cloudflare and Ookla servers, and both WireGuard and OpenVPN where available. I ran each server at least three times across morning, afternoon and evening peak hours over several weeks.
Streaming tests
I tested Netflix across several regional libraries and the other major streaming apps on both VPNs. When a geo-block appeared, I switched servers and counted how many hops it took.
Leak and kill switch tests
After every major configuration change I ran DNS, IPv6 and WebRTC leak tests. I also killed the VPN process and unplugged the network to confirm that traffic stopped.
Torrenting and support
I used a standard torrent client on Linux and checked whether port forwarding improved seeding. I also asked both support teams the same port forwarding question and compared the answers.
This is not lab testing, but it reflects how a heavy daily user lives with these VPNs. The numbers below are averages and ranges from those sessions, not cherry-picked peaks.
Speed Test Results: PIA vs PrivadoVPN
On nearby servers both VPNs were excellent. PrivadoVPN peaked at 700 to 900 Mbps on nearby European and US servers, while PIA usually sat between 500 and 800 Mbps on WireGuard.
| Test | PrivadoVPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Speed retention in my tests | 85% | 84% |
| Nearby server peak (WireGuard) | 700 to 900 Mbps | 500 to 800 Mbps |
| Added latency on nearby servers | Under 15 ms | Under 15 ms |
| Tokyo on a congested evening | About 160 Mbps | About 280 Mbps |
| Extra latency with multi-hop | Not emphasized | 40 to 80 ms |
| Kill switch and leak tests | Passed | Passed |
Long distance is where the larger PIA network helped. On a congested evening PIA reached roughly 280 Mbps to Tokyo, while the best PrivadoVPN option in Asia managed about 160 Mbps, although other nights narrowed or reversed that gap.
By speed retention, PrivadoVPN scored 85% and PIA scored 84%, so they are effectively tied. Surfshark One kept 96%, which is a clear step up from both.
Both kill switches cut traffic properly when I killed the VPN process and unplugged the network. Neither leaked my real IP in ipleak.net and similar tests.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
1. Surfshark One
Surfshark One is the VPN I would choose over both PIA and PrivadoVPN. It kept 96% of my baseline speed, the best retention in my tests, and it allows unlimited devices.
Surfshark One
The fastest VPN in my tests with unlimited devices and the best security bundle, from $2.49 per month on the 2-year plan.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- CleanWeb
- Fastest speeds in my tests
- Unlimited devices
- Antivirus and Alert included
- RAM-only servers
- Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Netherlands base (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price
The network covers 4500+ servers in 100+ countries and runs on RAM-only servers with a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy. That gives you audit proof like PIA, without the 10-device cap that PrivadoVPN has.
The One bundle also adds tools you would pay extra for elsewhere. Here is what stood out in daily use.
- Antivirus for malware protection on your devices
- Alert for breach monitoring
- Alternative ID for a disposable online identity
- Scam protection
- CleanWeb for blocking ads and trackers
- NoBorders for restrictive networks
- GPS override
- Everlink for staying connected
The downsides are real. Surfshark is based in the Netherlands (Nine Eyes), it is owned by Nord Security, and the renewal price is higher than the intro deal.
What I liked
- Best speed retention in my tests at 96%
- Unlimited devices on one subscription
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus, Alert and Alternative ID bundled in
- RAM-only servers and Deloitte-audited no-logs
What I didn’t like
- Netherlands base (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price than the intro deal
- Costs more than PrivadoVPN upfront
Read my full Surfshark One review or check the latest Surfshark coupon for the current discount. Deals change often, so check before you buy.
2. PrivadoVPN
PrivadoVPN is the cheapest VPN I track and the only one in this matchup with a free plan. The free plan gives you 10 GB every 30 days on one device, with no credit card needed.
PrivadoVPN
Best VPN with a free plan, from $1.11 per month on the 2-year plan, but with no published audit and a steep renewal.
- Free plan with 10 GB per month
- 10 simultaneous connections
- Ad blocker
- Parental controls
- SOCKS5 proxy
- Free plan with 10 GB per month
- Cheapest paid plans at $1.11 per month
- Iceland jurisdiction outside the Eyes alliances
- Ad blocker and threat protection on paid plans
- Parental controls and SOCKS5 proxy
- No published no-logs audit
- Renewal jumps to about $3.99 per month
- Only 10 connections on paid plans
- Smaller network than PIA
- No port forwarding or dedicated IP
Jurisdiction and Privacy
PrivadoVPN is Iceland-based. In the Terms of Service updated May 1, 2026, the contracting entity is Privado Networks ehf, registered in Garðabær near Reykjavik, and Icelandic law governs the terms.
Iceland sits outside the Five, Nine and Fourteen Eyes arrangements, which is the strongest jurisdiction argument in this comparison. The catch is that PrivadoVPN has never published a named independent audit, so its no-logs policy is a claim you take on trust.
Plans and Real Pricing
- Free: 10 GB every 30 days, 1 device and about 13 locations
- 1 month: $10.99 per month
- 12 months + 3 free: $1.33/mo, about $20 for 15 months
- 24 months + 3 free: $1.11/mo, $30 for 27 months
Paid plans allow 10 simultaneous connections, full server access and a 30-day money-back guarantee. The catch is renewal, because independent trackers show the 2-year plan renewing at about $3.99/mo ($95.76 every two years).
Security Tools and Features
- Ad blocker and threat prevention on paid plans
- Parental controls for family devices
- Email relay and Smart DNS
- SOCKS5 proxy for apps that prefer it
- WireGuard, OpenVPN and IKEv2 protocols
- Kill switch and split tunneling, stronger on Windows and Android
- Privado Sentry antivirus as a $1.99/mo add-on
The bundled tools were genuinely useful on family devices where I wanted basic protection without installing extra software. The apps are simple, and setup on mobile was fast for non-technical family members.
Speed was strong on nearby servers, but the smaller network showed on long routes and at peak hours. My speed retention was 85%, and I hit its limits when I needed a less common country or a specific US city.
What I liked
- Free plan with 10 GB per month and no credit card
- Cheapest paid plans at $1.11 per month
- Iceland jurisdiction outside the Eyes alliances
- Ad blocker, threat prevention and parental controls on paid plans
- Simple apps and quick setup
What I didn’t like
- No published independent no-logs audit
- Renewal jumps to about $3.99 per month
- Only 10 connections on paid plans
- Smaller network than PIA
- No port forwarding, dedicated IP or open-source apps
PrivadoVPN
Premium · 3 extra months
$1.11/mo
$30.00 upfront for 27 months
Read my full PrivadoVPN review or see the latest PrivadoVPN coupon for current pricing. Promotions change often, so check before you buy.
See How All 10 VPNs Compare
Not sure PIA or PrivadoVPN is right for you? See my full ranking of the best VPNs, tested and updated for 2026.
3. Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access, usually shortened to PIA, is the veteran of this matchup. It launched in 2010 and offers unlimited simultaneous devices, open-source apps and one of the most court-tested no-logs records in the industry.
Private Internet Access
Unlimited devices, open-source apps and audited no-logs for about $2.03 per month on the 3-year plan, but US-based and slower in my tests.
- Unlimited devices
- 113 countries and territories
- Open-source apps
- Port forwarding
- Multi-hop
- RAM-only servers
- Unlimited devices on every plan
- 113 countries and territories
- Open-source apps
- Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Port forwarding and multi-hop
- US base (Five Eyes)
- Owned by Kape
- No free plan
- Slower than PrivadoVPN and Surfshark One in my tests
- No parental controls
Ownership, Jurisdiction and Audits
PIA was founded in 2010 by Andrew Lee under London Trust Media. Kape Technologies acquired it in November 2019 for roughly $126 million, and Kape also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost.
The operating company is PIA Private Internet Access, Inc. in Denver, Colorado, so PIA sits inside the US and the Five Eyes alliance. That is the biggest mark against it for privacy purists, and Kape’s history, including its predecessor Crossrider, adds to the unease.
What offsets it is evidence. Deloitte audited the no-logs infrastructure in 2022 and 2024, and a full ISAE 3000 engagement completed in December 2025. PIA has also shown in US court cases that it had no usable subscriber data to hand over.
Plans and Real Pricing
- 1 month: $11.95 per month
- 1 year: $3.99/mo ($47.88 billed annually)
- 3 years plus extra months: $2.03/mo ($79 for 39 months)
During the early Black Friday window the buy page also showed $1.89/mo for 40 months (about $75.60), so check the live price. The long plan renews at roughly $2.10 per month equivalent, which is among the best long-term rates in the industry.
Every plan allows unlimited simultaneous connections and includes a 30-day money-back guarantee for new direct subscribers. Dedicated IP and Antivirus are add-ons that discount more heavily on longer plans.
Features I Actually Used
- Open-source apps you can read on GitHub
- RAM-only servers that wipe on reboot
- Multi-hop routing, which added 40 to 80 ms of latency
- MACE ad and tracker blocker
- Split tunneling on all desktop platforms
- Port forwarding on selected servers
- Dedicated IP add-on in limited locations, which reduced captchas on some banking sites
- Email breach monitor included with the subscription
The desktop apps are dense with options, which power users love and beginners may find overwhelming. Linux support is strong, and OpenVPN config files worked on my travel router for the whole household.
My speed retention was 84%, slightly behind PrivadoVPN, although PIA won my long-distance tests thanks to its larger network. It also has no parental controls, which PrivadoVPN includes on paid plans.
What I liked
- Unlimited devices on every plan
- 113 countries and territories, including every US state
- Open-source apps, RAM-only servers and Deloitte audits
- Port forwarding and multi-hop for power users
- Low renewal rate on the long plan
What I didn’t like
- US base inside the Five Eyes alliance
- Owned by Kape, with Crossrider history
- No free plan
- Dense desktop apps for beginners
- No parental controls
Read my full Private Internet Access review or see the latest Private Internet Access coupon for current pricing. Black Friday rates in particular change fast.
PIA vs PrivadoVPN Pricing Compared
Pricing is where these two diverge the most. PrivadoVPN is cheaper to start, while PIA is cheaper to keep.
| Plan | PrivadoVPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | 10 GB per 30 days, 1 device | None |
| 1 month | $10.99 | $11.95 |
| 12 months | $1.33/mo ($20 for 15 months) | $3.99/mo ($47.88 for 12 months) |
| Longest plan | $1.11/mo ($30 for 27 months) | $2.03/mo ($79 for 39 months) |
| Typical renewal | About $3.99/mo ($95.76 every 2 years) | About $2.10/mo equivalent on the 3-year plan |
| Devices | 10 on paid plans | Unlimited |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | 30 days |
Five-Year Cost Estimate
Here is my math if renewal prices stay as listed. I used a 75-month window because it fits both long plans plus renewals.
- PrivadoVPN: $30 for 27 months plus two renewals of $95.76 is about $221.52, or roughly $2.95 per month.
- PIA: $79 for 39 months plus one renewal of about $75.60 is about $154.60, or roughly $2.06 per month.
If you leave before the first renewal, PrivadoVPN is clearly cheaper. If you stay for several years, PIA’s low renewal rate wins.
Real-World Cost Scenarios
- Two devices, cancel after 24 months: PrivadoVPN wins at $30.
- Large household for years: PIA wins thanks to unlimited connections and a low renewal.
- Want to try before paying: only PrivadoVPN has a free plan.
- Need a dedicated IP for banking logins: PIA offers it as an add-on.
Which Is More Private: PIA or PrivadoVPN?
Ownership and jurisdiction decide who can compel a VPN to keep or hand over data. Here is the evidence side by side.
| Factor | PrivadoVPN | Private Internet Access |
|---|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | Iceland, outside Five, Nine and Fourteen Eyes | United States (Colorado), Five Eyes |
| Operating company | Privado Networks ehf | PIA Private Internet Access, Inc., owned by Kape |
| Independent audits | None published | Deloitte in 2022, 2024 and December 2025 |
| Court-tested | No public record I could cite | Yes, no activity logs to hand over |
| Open-source apps | No | Yes |
| RAM-only servers | Not publicly confirmed | Yes |
| Kill switch | Yes, passed my tests | Yes, passed my tests |
If you mainly worry about everyday tracking and data brokers, either VPN is fine. If a specific government is your concern, the Deloitte audits and court record tilt me toward PIA, while Iceland tilts jurisdiction purists toward PrivadoVPN.
I value the combination of open-source code, public audits and courtroom proof more than jurisdiction alone. The important thing is to know what evidence exists rather than relying on marketing language.
Server Networks: 113 Countries vs About 60
This is where PIA’s scale becomes obvious. It lists locations in 113 countries and territories, including every US state, and independent reviews cite 30,000 to 35,000+ servers because PIA does not publish an exact count.
Many PIA locations are virtual, which is common industry practice. PrivadoVPN is far smaller, with about 49 to 63 countries, about 66 city locations and hundreds of servers, and free users are limited to about 13 locations.
Where PrivadoVPN Worked Well
- US East and West
- The UK and Germany
- The Netherlands
- Japan and Singapore
Outside the top 20 countries, PIA almost always had an option when I needed a less common country or a specific US city for a regional sports blackout. PrivadoVPN left me stuck more often. For comparison, Surfshark One runs 4500+ servers in 100+ countries.
Streaming and Torrenting
Streaming
Both VPNs unblocked the major services in my tests, with occasional geo-blocks that cleared after a server switch. PIA’s larger list of streaming-optimized locations gave it a slight edge for more obscure catalogs.
- Netflix in the US and UK worked on both
- Disney+ and Hulu worked on both
- BBC iPlayer worked on both
- Amazon Prime Video worked on both
PIA needed fewer server hops on average. If you watch on a TV stick, see my guides to the best VPN for Firestick and the best VPN for Amazon Prime Video.
Torrenting and P2P
PIA allows torrenting on most servers, but not all US ones, and supports port forwarding on selected locations. I used port forwarding on a Linux seedbox-style setup and it worked as advertised.
PrivadoVPN permits P2P across the network but does not advertise port forwarding. For casual downloading either is fine, but for heavy seeding PIA has the clear advantage.
Apps, Usability and Support
PIA’s mobile apps are cleaner than its desktop apps, and unlimited devices meant I never had to decide who gets kicked off. On PrivadoVPN I occasionally had to disconnect an old tablet or a guest’s phone.
PrivadoVPN’s apps are simpler and more approachable, and its shorter server list is easy to scan. PIA’s list is long enough that search becomes essential, so I favorited a handful of locations.
- Support: both offer 24/7 chat, and PIA’s answers were faster and more technical.
- Port forwarding question: PIA replied within minutes with the right help-center link, while PrivadoVPN was slower and more generic.
- Browser extensions: both have them, and I used the PIA Chrome extension on a work laptop.
- Routers: both support manual OpenVPN configs, but PrivadoVPN’s documentation was thinner.
- Network switching: both kept the tunnel up when I moved between Wi-Fi and mobile data.
Both money-back guarantees worked as advertised when I briefly canceled and re-subscribed during testing. Refunds arrived within a few business days on purchases made directly from the websites.
Who Should Choose PIA or PrivadoVPN?
Choose PrivadoVPN if
- You want to try a free plan first
- Price is your top priority and you only need up to 10 devices
- Icelandic jurisdiction is a must-have
- You want parental controls and an ad blocker on paid plans
- You are fine with a smaller server network
- You prefer a simpler app
Choose PIA if
- You have more than 10 devices in the household
- You want the lowest long-term renewal rate
- Audited and court-tested no-logs matters more than jurisdiction
- You need servers in many countries or specific US states
- You like open-source apps, multi-hop and port forwarding
- You torrent or seed regularly
Why Surfshark One Still Beats Both
Put all three side by side and Surfshark One is the only one without a major trade-off on speed, devices and privacy proof. It costs $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan ($67.23 for 27 months), which sits between PrivadoVPN and PIA.
- Speed retention: 96% versus 85% for PrivadoVPN and 84% for PIA
- Devices: unlimited, like PIA and unlike PrivadoVPN’s 10
- Audits: Deloitte-audited no-logs, which PrivadoVPN lacks
- Extras: Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID and scam protection included
- Trade-offs: Netherlands base, Nord Security ownership and a higher renewal
If you only want the absolute lowest price, PrivadoVPN still wins, and my best cheap VPN guide covers more budget options. Otherwise the extra cost over PIA is small for the speed and bundle you get.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
Frequently Asked Questions
Is PIA VPN better than PrivadoVPN?
It depends on your priorities. PIA wins on unlimited devices, open-source apps, audits and a larger network, while PrivadoVPN wins on price, its free plan and Icelandic jurisdiction. For most budget buyers with up to 10 devices I rank PrivadoVPN slightly higher, and for big households PIA is the better fit.
Is PrivadoVPN really free?
Yes, the free plan gives you 10 GB every 30 days on one device, with no credit card required. It is limited to roughly 13 locations, and the allowance resets every 30 days. Paid plans unlock all servers and 10 simultaneous connections.
Which is cheaper, PIA or PrivadoVPN?
PrivadoVPN is cheaper upfront at $1.11/mo ($30 for 27 months) versus $2.03/mo ($79 for 39 months) for PIA. Over five years PIA came out cheaper in my estimate, because PrivadoVPN renews at about $3.99/mo while PIA renews at roughly $2.10/mo.
How many devices can I use with each VPN?
PIA allows unlimited simultaneous connections on every plan. PrivadoVPN allows 10 on paid plans and 1 on the free plan. Surfshark One also allows unlimited devices.
Is PrivadoVPN safe, and does it keep logs?
PrivadoVPN says it keeps no activity logs and is based in Iceland, outside the Five, Nine and Fourteen Eyes alliances. However, it has never published a named independent audit, so the claim rests on trust. It passed my kill switch and leak tests without exposing my real IP.
Is PIA safe given that it is owned by Kape and based in the US?
PIA has open-source apps, RAM-only servers, Deloitte audits in 2022, 2024 and December 2025, and court cases where it had no activity logs to hand over. The US base and Kape ownership still bother some privacy purists. If a specific government is your threat, weigh that carefully.
Which VPN is faster, PIA or PrivadoVPN?
Nearby, PrivadoVPN peaked higher at 700 to 900 Mbps against 500 to 800 Mbps for PIA. On long routes such as Asia, PIA’s bigger network gave me better results. Overall speed retention was 85% for PrivadoVPN and 84% for PIA, while Surfshark One reached 96%.
Which works better for Netflix and streaming?
Both unblocked the major services in my tests, with occasional blocks that cleared after a server switch. PIA’s larger list of streaming locations gave it a slight edge and fewer server hops on average. For Prime Video specifically, see my best VPN for Amazon Prime Video guide.
Which is better for torrenting?
Both allow P2P traffic. PIA supports port forwarding on selected servers, which helps seeding, while PrivadoVPN does not advertise it. For heavy seeding I pick PIA.
Can I get a dedicated IP or port forwarding?
PIA offers a dedicated IP as an add-on in limited locations and port forwarding on selected servers. PrivadoVPN offers neither.
Do PIA and PrivadoVPN have a money-back guarantee?
Yes, both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee for new paid subscribers who buy directly from their websites. My refund arrived within a few business days.
What is the best VPN if I do not want either one?
Surfshark One is my top pick, with unlimited devices and 96% speed retention in my tests. For more options see my best VPNs ranking and the best cheap VPN guide.
Final Verdict: PIA VPN vs PrivadoVPN
PrivadoVPN is the better pick for most budget buyers who need up to 10 devices and want a free plan to test first. PIA is the better pick for big households, power users and anyone who values audits, open-source apps and port forwarding.
PrivadoVPN edges PIA in my ranking mainly because of its price, free plan and jurisdiction. I still keep PIA as my primary for unlimited devices and audited privacy, and I keep PrivadoVPN installed on a spare device for the free plan.
Neither beats Surfshark One. For about $0.46 more per month than the PIA 3-year deal, you get 96% speed retention, unlimited devices and a bundled security suite.
Surfshark One
Surfshark One pairs a fast network of 4500+ servers in 100+ countries with antivirus, breach alerts and an alternative identity tool.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- CleanWeb







