TL;DR
- For most people, IPVanish beats Private Internet Access in this matchup because it is faster (93% vs 84% speed retention in my tests), while PIA wins on port forwarding and privacy extras.
- My number one VPN overall is Surfshark One at $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan ($67.23 for 27 months, 3 months free) with 96% speed retention.
- IPVanish costs $2.19/mo on the 2-year Essential plan ($52.56 for 24 months), and Private Internet Access costs $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan ($79 for 39 months).
- The key caveat is that IPVanish renews at $99.99/yr and has no port forwarding, while Private Internet Access is the slower of the two.
- IPVanish suits speed fans and Fire TV users, and Private Internet Access suits torrenters and privacy purists who want open-source apps.
This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase a VPN through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences our reviews or rankings.
Surfshark One
Surfshark One kept 96% of my speed, ahead of both IPVanish and PIA, and bundles antivirus and identity tools into one plan. It is still my number one pick at $2.49/mo.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- Scam protection
- CleanWeb
- NoBorders
- GPS override
- Everlink
- RAM-only servers
- Fastest in my tests with 96% speed retention
- Unlimited devices
- RAM-only servers and Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Antivirus and Alert bundled in
- Based in the Netherlands (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price
PIA vs IPVanish is one of the closest VPN matchups I have tested. Both are based in the United States, both give you unlimited simultaneous connections, and both undercut most rivals on price. I spent a month running them through speed, streaming, torrenting and privacy tests.
The short version is that IPVanish is faster and easier to live with. PIA is the more privacy-focused option, with 100% RAM-only servers, open-source apps and port forwarding. Neither beats Surfshark One, which is still my number one pick overall.
Below you will find every test result, the real renewal prices and the pros and cons I ran into along the way. I tell you where each VPN let me down, because that is what actually helps you choose.
Deals verified November 21, 2026
Every price in this article was checked against the live checkout pages on this date.
PIA vs IPVanish: Quick Ranked List
- 1. Surfshark One: best overall, fastest in my tests (96% speed retention), $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan.
- 2. IPVanish: best of the two for speed, unlimited devices and TV apps (93% speed retention), $2.19/mo on the 2-year Essential plan.
- 3. Private Internet Access: best of the two for port forwarding and privacy tools (84% speed retention), $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan.
Surfshark One
Fastest VPN in my tests with a full security bundle and unlimited devices.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers
- Antivirus
- RAM-only servers
IPVanish
Rebuilt 50 Gbps network, unlimited devices and great Fire TV and Apple TV apps.
- Unlimited devices
- 3650+ servers
- Threat Protection
- Live 24/7 chat
Private Internet Access
Open-source apps, 100% RAM-only servers and native port forwarding for torrenting.
- Unlimited devices
- Port forwarding
- Open-source apps
- MACE ad blocker
PIA vs IPVanish vs Surfshark One at a Glance
| Feature | Surfshark One | IPVanish | PIA |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Best overall | Speed and unlimited devices | Port forwarding and privacy tools |
| Price | $2.49/mo ($67.23 for 27 months) | $2.19/mo Essential ($52.56 for 24 months) | $2.03/mo ($79 for 39 months) |
| Speed retention in my tests | 96% | 93% | 84% |
| Servers | 4500+ in 100+ countries | 3650+ in 150+ locations | 180 locations in 113 countries |
| Devices | Unlimited | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| Headquarters | Netherlands (Nine Eyes) | US (Five Eyes) | US (Five Eyes) |
| RAM-only servers | Yes | Part of the network | Yes, 100% |
| No-logs proof | Deloitte audit | Audited twice | Deloitte audit and US court cases |
| Port forwarding | No | No | Yes |
| Biggest con | Higher renewal | Renews at $99.99/yr | Slowest of the three |
| My verdict | Best overall | Best of the two for most people | Best of the two for torrenting |
How I Tested PIA and IPVanish
I tested both VPNs for a month on a 1 Gbps fiber connection in Western Europe. My baseline without a VPN was 940 Mbps down and 920 Mbps up, with a 3ms ping.
I used WireGuard on both apps, which is the default on PIA and the fastest protocol on IPVanish. Speed retention in this article means the share of my baseline speed each VPN kept.
- Speed tests on local, transatlantic (New York) and long-distance (Sydney) servers
- Streaming tests on Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max and BBC iPlayer
- Torrenting and port forwarding checks
- Kill switch drop tests with DNS, IPv6 and WebRTC leak checks on ipleak.net
- Privacy policy, ownership and audit research
- Live chat support tests with a technical WireGuard MTU question
PIA vs IPVanish Speed Test Results
| Test | IPVanish | PIA |
|---|---|---|
| Speed retention overall | 93% | 84% |
| Local server ping | 9ms | 12ms |
| New York download | 490 Mbps | 420 Mbps |
| New York upload | 410 Mbps | 380 Mbps |
| Sydney download | 210 Mbps | 180 Mbps |
| Sydney ping | Not recorded | 240ms |
IPVanish was faster on every hop I tested, squeezing out 5% to 15% more bandwidth than PIA. On a local server it was almost indistinguishable from my bare fiber line, at about 880 Mbps.
PIA is still fast enough for 4K streaming, big downloads and heavy torrenting. Even the 240ms ping to Sydney felt stable, because the bandwidth held up. Surfshark One beat both with 96% speed retention.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
1. Surfshark One
Surfshark One is my number one VPN, and it beats both IPVanish and PIA on speed and bundle value. You get unlimited devices, 4500+ servers in 100+ countries, RAM-only servers and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy.
The One bundle adds Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID and scam protection, on top of CleanWeb, NoBorders, GPS override and Everlink. At $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan ($67.23 for 27 months, with 3 months free), it is only slightly above IPVanish and PIA.
What I liked
- Fastest of the three in my tests at 96% speed retention
- Unlimited devices on one account
- Antivirus, Alert and Alternative ID bundled in
- RAM-only servers and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy
What I didn’t like
- Based in the Netherlands, a Nine Eyes country
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price than the intro deal
Read my Surfshark One review or check the Surfshark coupon page for the latest deal.
2. IPVanish
IPVanish is the faster VPN in this matchup and the one I would pick for most households. It keeps 93% of my baseline speed, supports unlimited devices and runs a rebuilt 50 Gbps network.
IPVanish
IPVanish is the faster of the two, keeping 93% of my speed with unlimited devices and a rebuilt 50 Gbps network. Watch the $99.99 per year renewal.
- Unlimited devices
- 3650+ servers in 150+ locations
- 56000+ shared IPs
- Threat Protection on Essential
- Twice-audited no-logs
- Live 24/7 chat
- 93% speed retention
- Unlimited devices
- Great Fire TV and Apple TV apps
- Live 24/7 chat on every plan
- US based (Five Eyes)
- Renews at $99.99 per year
- No port forwarding
- Only part of the network is RAM-only
IPVanish has a long history in the VPN world, and it has changed a lot in the last two years. Here is what I found after a month of daily use.
Network and Speed
IPVanish runs 3650+ servers in 150+ locations with 56000+ shared IP addresses. It spent two years rebuilding the network on custom AMD EPYC Genoa hardware with dual 25 Gbps bonded uplinks, which gives each server 50 Gbps of total capacity.
The results showed. I measured about 880 Mbps on a local server, 490 Mbps to New York and 210 Mbps to Sydney, all with WireGuard.
Privacy and Ownership
IPVanish is owned by Ziff Davis, the company behind IGN, Mashable and Everyday Health, and it is based in the US, a Five Eyes country. In 2016, under previous ownership, it handed user logs to the Department of Homeland Security despite promising a no-logs policy.
Since the Ziff Davis acquisition, the no-logs policy has been audited twice and the backend has been rebuilt. Only part of the network is RAM-only, which IPVanish put at roughly 35% (880+ servers across 25 locations) in mid-2026, and the apps are closed-source.
Streaming and Apps
IPVanish unblocked US Netflix, UK Netflix and Disney+ for me on standard servers, helped by 16000 new IP addresses added in 2026. Amazon Prime Video threw a few proxy errors, and BBC iPlayer took three UK servers before it worked.
The Fire TV and Apple TV apps are some of the best I have used, and the desktop app shows a live speed graph I genuinely like. Threat Protection comes on the Essential plan, while Next Gen Antivirus is on Complete and Advanced (desktop only).
IPVanish Pricing
- 1 month (Essential): $14.99/mo
- 1 year (Essential): $3.89/mo, billed at $46.68 for the first year, then $99.99/yr
- 2 years (Essential): $2.19/mo, billed at $52.56 for 24 months, then $99.99/yr
- Complete (2 years): $2.79/mo, which adds Next Gen Antivirus
- Advanced (2 years): $3.29/mo
Treat the renewal price as the real price. If you pick IPVanish, set a calendar reminder before your term ends so you are not surprised by $99.99 a year.
What I liked
- Fast, with 93% speed retention in my tests
- Unlimited devices on every plan
- Great Fire TV and Apple TV apps
- Twice-audited no-logs policy
- Live 24/7 chat on every plan
What I didn’t like
- Based in the US (Five Eyes)
- Renews at $99.99/yr
- No port forwarding
- Only part of the network is RAM-only
- Closed-source apps
I keep the current IPVanish discount, including the 3 GB eSIM data gift, updated in the box below.
IPVanish
Essential · 2-year plan
$2.19/mo
$52.56 upfront for 24 months
For the full breakdown, read my IPVanish review or the IPVanish coupon page.
See how all 10 VPNs rank
Not sure PIA or IPVanish is right for you? Compare every VPN I have tested in my full ranking, led by Surfshark One.
3. Private Internet Access (PIA)
PIA is the privacy purist’s pick in this matchup. It runs 100% RAM-only servers, ships open-source apps and offers native port forwarding, which IPVanish does not.
Private Internet Access
PIA is the better pick for torrenting and privacy purists, with port forwarding, open-source apps and 100% RAM-only servers. It is the slower of the two in my tests.
- Unlimited devices
- Port forwarding
- Open-source apps
- 100% RAM-only servers
- MACE ad blocker
- Streaming-optimized servers
- Native port forwarding
- Open-source apps
- 100% RAM-only servers
- Unlimited devices
- 84% speed retention
- US based (Five Eyes)
- Needs the 3-year plan for the best price
- Settings can overwhelm beginners
PIA has the strongest privacy track record of the two. Here is how it held up in my testing.
Network and Speed
PIA now lists servers in 180 locations across 113 countries, including recent additions in the Caribbean, Central Asia and Africa. For hard-to-reach places it uses geo-located virtual servers, so you get a local IP while the hardware sits in a more secure neighboring country.
PIA kept 84% of my baseline speed. That is the slowest of the three VPNs in this article, but I still got 420 Mbps to New York and 180 Mbps to Sydney, which is plenty for 4K and torrenting.
Privacy and Ownership
PIA is owned by Kape Technologies, which also owns ExpressVPN and CyberGhost. Kape started life as Crossrider and had adware associations, but PIA itself has one of the best privacy records in the industry.
Its no-logs claim has been tested in US court cases where subpoenas produced no identifying data, and it has been audited by Deloitte. The apps are open-source and the whole network is RAM-only, which IPVanish cannot match yet.
Streaming, Torrenting and Apps
PIA labels dedicated streaming-optimized servers in 35 locations. I got US Netflix in 4K, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, Disney+, Amazon Prime Video and HBO Max working, and a quick reconnect fixed the rare blocked server.
For torrenting, every server allows P2P and PIA has built-in port forwarding. The desktop app is a playground for tinkerers, with MTU control, custom DNS, split tunneling and draggable widgets, plus a full graphical app on Linux.
PIA Pricing
- 1 month: $11.95/mo
- 1 year: $3.99/mo, billed at $47.88 per year
- 3 years: $2.03/mo, billed at $79 for 39 months (3 months free)
- Dedicated IP add-on: around $3 to $5/mo extra
PIA has one tier with every feature included, including the MACE ad, tracker and malware blocker. That keeps pricing simple, but the best price needs a 3-year commitment.
What I liked
- Native port forwarding
- Open-source apps you can inspect on GitHub
- 100% RAM-only network
- No-logs record proven in US court cases
- Dedicated streaming servers in 35 locations
What I didn’t like
- Slowest of the three at 84% speed retention
- Based in the US (Five Eyes)
- Kape ownership and its adware history
- Best price needs a 3-year commitment
- Many settings can overwhelm beginners
Read my PIA review or check the PIA coupon page for current pricing.
PIA vs IPVanish: Head-to-Head Comparison
Background, Ownership and Jurisdiction
Both VPNs are based in the US, a founding Five Eyes country, so a no-logs policy matters more than the jurisdiction itself. PIA is owned by Kape Technologies, and IPVanish is owned by Ziff Davis.
PIA’s no-logs claim has survived US court subpoenas, and IPVanish handed over logs in 2016 under previous owners. IPVanish has been audited twice since, but PIA has the cleaner track record.
Winner: PIA.
Pricing and Value
IPVanish is cheaper upfront, at $2.19/mo for 24 months versus $79 for 39 months on PIA. On a per-month basis PIA is cheaper at $2.03/mo, but it needs a 3-year commitment.
The renewal is where they split. IPVanish jumps to $99.99/yr, while PIA’s 1-year plan renews at the same $47.88. IPVanish also charges $14.99 for a single month versus $11.95 on PIA.
Winner: PIA, because of the gentler renewals.
Server Network
IPVanish offers 3650+ servers in 150+ locations with 56000+ IP addresses and 50 Gbps of capacity per server. PIA lists 180 locations across 113 countries and uses virtual servers for hard-to-reach regions.
Winner: Tie. Both networks are elite.
Speed
IPVanish kept 93% of my baseline speed and PIA kept 84%. IPVanish was 5% to 15% faster on local, New York and Sydney tests.
Winner: IPVanish.
Security, Privacy and Protocols
Both support WireGuard and OpenVPN with AES-256-GCM or ChaCha20 encryption. Both kill switches stopped my traffic when I killed the VPN process, with no DNS, IPv6 or WebRTC leaks on ipleak.net.
PIA pulls ahead with 100% RAM-only servers, open-source apps and Shadowsocks and SOCKS5 proxies for strict censorship firewalls. IPVanish counters with a Double Hop feature and Threat Protection, but it is closed-source and only partly RAM-only.
Winner: PIA.
Streaming
PIA has labeled streaming-optimized servers in 35 locations and unblocked every service I tried. IPVanish unblocked US Netflix, UK Netflix and Disney+, but needed trial and error on Prime Video and BBC iPlayer.
Winner: PIA.
Torrenting
Both allow P2P on every server. IPVanish adds a SOCKS5 proxy and raw speed, but it has no port forwarding, which PIA includes natively and which helps you connect to more peers.
Winner: PIA.
Apps and Interface
PIA is deeply customizable, with a draggable dashboard, MTU and DNS controls and a full Linux GUI. IPVanish has a cleaner, more beginner-friendly app with a live speed graph, a RAM-only server filter and standout Fire TV and Apple TV apps.
Winner: Tie. Tinkerers will prefer PIA, and TV users will prefer IPVanish.
Customer Support
Both offer 24/7 live chat with extensive knowledge bases. PIA put me through to a human in about 45 seconds, while IPVanish sent me to a bot first and then a human in about 2 minutes.
Winner: Tie. PIA was a little quicker, but both agents were helpful.
Devices and Compatibility
Both VPNs offer unlimited simultaneous connections, so you can protect every device in your home. Both have apps for Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android, Android TV and Fire TV.
Winner: Tie.
Scorecard
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Background and jurisdiction | PIA |
| Pricing and value | PIA |
| Server network | Tie |
| Speed | IPVanish |
| Security and privacy | PIA |
| Streaming | PIA |
| Torrenting | PIA |
| Apps and interface | Tie |
| Customer support | Tie |
| Devices and compatibility | Tie |
Why Surfshark One Beats Both PIA and IPVanish
PIA wins more individual rounds, but IPVanish wins the one you feel every day, which is speed. Surfshark One beats both on that front, with 96% speed retention versus 93% and 84%.
It also bundles Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID and scam protection, which neither rival matches in a single plan. At $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan, with 3 months free, it costs only a little more than IPVanish and PIA.
- Faster than both in my tests
- Unlimited devices, like IPVanish and PIA
- RAM-only servers and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy
- Drawbacks: Netherlands base (Nine Eyes), Nord Security ownership and a higher renewal
If you want a deeper look at how it compares to a bigger rival, read my Surfshark vs NordVPN comparison.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
PIA vs IPVanish Pricing Compared
| Plan | IPVanish | PIA |
|---|---|---|
| 1 month | $14.99/mo (Essential) | $11.95/mo |
| 1 year | $3.89/mo ($46.68 first year) | $3.99/mo ($47.88) |
| Best long-term deal | $2.19/mo ($52.56 for 24 months) | $2.03/mo ($79 for 39 months) |
| Renewal | $99.99/yr | $47.88/yr on the 1-year plan |
| Higher tiers | Complete $2.79/mo, Advanced $3.29/mo (2 years) | One tier with everything included |
| Extras | 3 GB eSIM data gift | 3 months free on the 3-year plan |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | 30 days |
On sticker price the two are within cents of each other, so the renewal is what should decide it. If you want to avoid a jump to $99.99 a year, PIA is the safer budget choice.
Both come with a 30-day money-back guarantee, so you can test either one risk free. You can check live prices on my VPN deals page and my best cheap VPN guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is IPVanish better than PIA?
For most people, yes, because IPVanish is faster (93% vs 84% speed retention in my tests) and easier to use. PIA is better for torrenting, port forwarding and open-source transparency.
Which is faster, PIA or IPVanish?
IPVanish. It was 5% to 15% faster than PIA on local, New York and Sydney tests, thanks to its rebuilt 50 Gbps network.
Which is better for torrenting?
PIA, because it has native port forwarding and allows P2P on every server. IPVanish also allows P2P everywhere and is faster, but it has no port forwarding.
Which is better for streaming?
PIA has dedicated streaming-optimized servers in 35 locations and unblocked every service I tested. IPVanish works with Netflix and Disney+, but needed more trial and error on Prime Video and BBC iPlayer.
Do PIA and IPVanish keep logs?
Neither keeps logs according to their audits and policies. PIA’s no-logs claim has been proven in US court cases and audited by Deloitte, and IPVanish has been audited twice since its 2016 log incident under previous owners.
Are PIA and IPVanish safe, given they are US based?
Both are in the US, a Five Eyes country, but jurisdiction only matters if logs exist. PIA runs 100% RAM-only servers, while only part of IPVanish’s network is RAM-only.
Do they offer unlimited devices?
Yes. Both IPVanish and PIA allow unlimited simultaneous connections on a single account.
Which is cheaper, PIA or IPVanish?
PIA is cheaper per month at $2.03/mo on the 3-year plan, and IPVanish costs $2.19/mo on the 2-year plan. IPVanish renews at $99.99/yr, so PIA is cheaper over the long run.
Does IPVanish work on Fire TV and Apple TV?
Yes, and the apps are some of the best I have used. See my best VPN for Firestick guide for more options.
Is there a better option than PIA and IPVanish?
In my testing, Surfshark One is the best overall VPN at $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan. It was faster than both, with 96% speed retention, and it includes antivirus and identity tools.
Final Verdict: PIA vs IPVanish
PIA wins more individual categories, but IPVanish is the one I would recommend to most people. It is noticeably faster, simpler to use and has excellent TV apps, which is why it ranks higher on my list.
PIA is the better choice if privacy and torrenting are your priority. It runs a 100% RAM-only network, ships open-source apps and is the only one of the two with port forwarding.
Choose IPVanish if:
- You want the faster VPN, especially on a gigabit connection
- You use Fire TV or Apple TV a lot
- You want a simple app with a live speed graph
- You are fine setting a reminder before the $99.99/yr renewal
Choose PIA if:
- You torrent and need port forwarding
- You want open-source apps and a 100% RAM-only network
- You want cleaner renewal pricing
- You like to tweak settings like MTU, DNS and split tunneling
If you want the best of both worlds, I still recommend Surfshark One. It is faster than both and bundles antivirus and identity protection, and you can try it with a 30-day money-back guarantee.
Surfshark One
My number one VPN: faster than IPVanish and PIA in my tests, with unlimited devices and a full security bundle.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- RAM-only servers







