TL;DR
- IPVanish is the better pick for budget and big households (unlimited devices from $2.19/mo), while Proton VPN is the better pick for privacy (Swiss, open source, free plan).
- In my tests IPVanish kept 93% of my baseline speed and Proton VPN kept 92%, so speed will not decide this one.
- My overall top pick is Surfshark One at $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan, with up to 88% off plus 3 months free.
- The key caveats: IPVanish is US based (Five Eyes) and renews at $99.99+ per year, while Proton VPN caps you at 10 devices and renews at $83.88/yr.
- Choose IPVanish for families and bargain hunters, Proton VPN for journalists and privacy purists, and Surfshark One if you want the best all-rounder.
This page contains affiliate links. If you purchase a VPN through our links we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. This never influences our reviews or rankings.
Surfshark One
I rank Surfshark One above both IPVanish and Proton VPN. It was the fastest in my tests at 96% speed retention, covers unlimited devices and bundles a full security suite from $2.49/mo.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- RAM-only servers
- Fastest in my tests
- Unlimited devices
- Antivirus and Alert bundled
- RAM-only servers
- Deloitte-audited no-logs
- Netherlands based (Nine Eyes)
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price
Proton VPN and IPVanish are two of the VPNs I get asked about most, and on paper they could not be more different. One is a Swiss privacy specialist from the team behind Proton Mail, while the other is a fast, US based VPN built around unlimited device connections.
I have made 600+ VPN videos over the last 3+ years, so I skipped the marketing claims and compared what actually decides a purchase. That means price and renewals, speed, privacy, streaming, torrenting, apps and support.
Below you get my verdict on each VPN, a full head-to-head comparison and a clear recommendation. I also rank a third VPN above both of them, and I explain exactly why.
Deals verified November 20, 2026
I checked every price in this article today. The 2-year prices below are introductory prices for the first term, so read the renewal notes before you buy.
Proton VPN vs IPVanish: Quick Ranking
Here is how the VPNs in this comparison rank in my testing. Each one has a clear job, and the right choice depends on what you care about most.
- Surfshark One: best overall, fastest and best bundle, from $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan.
- IPVanish: unlimited connections, fast and budget friendly, from $2.19/mo on the 2-year Essential plan.
- Proton VPN: the privacy pick, with a free plan and $2.99/mo on the 2-year plan.
Surfshark One
The fastest VPN in my tests with unlimited devices and a full security bundle.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
IPVanish
Fast, unlimited connections and the cheapest way to cover a whole household.
- Unlimited devices
- 3650+ servers in 150+ locations
- 50Gbps network
- 24/7 live chat
Proton VPN
The privacy pick: Swiss based, open source, audited and with a real free plan.
- 10 devices
- 20000+ servers in 140+ countries
- Open-source apps
- Free plan available
Proton VPN vs IPVanish: Head-to-Head Comparison
This table puts the hard numbers side by side. I used the 2-year introductory price for each VPN, which is how most people buy.
| Feature | IPVanish | Proton VPN |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Unlimited devices and budget | Privacy |
| 2-year price | $2.19/mo Essential ($52.56 for 24 months) | $2.99/mo VPN Plus ($71.76 for 24 months) |
| Renewal price | $99.99+ per year | $83.88 per year |
| Servers | 3650+ in 150+ locations | 20000+ in 140+ countries |
| Simultaneous devices | Unlimited | 10 |
| Speed retention in my tests | 93% | 92% |
| Jurisdiction | United States (Five Eyes) | Switzerland |
| No-logs policy | Twice audited | Audited |
| Open-source apps | No | Yes |
| Free plan | No | Yes, with unlimited data |
| Port forwarding | No | Yes |
| Antivirus | Next Gen Antivirus on Complete and Advanced (desktop only) | Not included |
| Support | Live 24/7 chat on every plan | Live chat and priority support on paid plans |
| Money-back guarantee | 30 days | 30 days |
The pattern is clear. IPVanish wins on price, devices and a hair of speed, while Proton VPN wins on jurisdiction, transparency and the size of its network.
How I Tested Proton VPN and IPVanish
I tested both VPNs on the same connection with the default WireGuard protocol. Speed is the share of my baseline download speed that each VPN kept, which I call speed retention.
Beyond speed, I judged each provider on the areas that matter in daily use:
- Price, discounts and what the plan costs at renewal.
- Privacy: jurisdiction, no-logs audits and open-source status.
- Streaming performance on popular libraries.
- Torrenting and P2P support.
- App quality across desktop, mobile and TV.
- Customer support response and quality.
Speed Results: IPVanish vs Proton VPN
Both VPNs are fast, and they land within one percentage point of each other. IPVanish kept 93% of my baseline speed and Proton VPN kept 92%, so you will not feel the difference in everyday use.
IPVanish benefits from a rebuilt 50Gbps network, which helps when the network is busy. Proton VPN counters with a huge server count that spreads the load, so I rarely hit a crowded server.
| VPN | Speed retention | 2-year price |
|---|---|---|
| Surfshark One | 96% | $2.49/mo ($67.23 for 27 months) |
| IPVanish | 93% | $2.19/mo ($52.56 for 24 months) |
| Proton VPN | 92% | $2.99/mo ($71.76 for 24 months) |
If raw speed is your top priority, neither of these two is my first choice. Surfshark One kept 96% in the same tests, which makes it the fastest VPN I have measured.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
1. Surfshark One: The VPN I Rank Above Both
Both IPVanish and Proton VPN are good VPNs, but Surfshark One is the one I would buy first. It kept 96% of my baseline speed, ahead of IPVanish at 93% and Proton VPN at 92%.
Like IPVanish, it covers unlimited devices, so one subscription protects the whole household. It also bundles a security suite with Antivirus, Alert, Alternative ID and scam protection.
On the network side you get 4500+ servers in 100+ countries, RAM-only servers and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy. Day to day, these extras stand out:
- CleanWeb to block ads and malicious sites.
- NoBorders for use in restricted regions.
- GPS override on mobile.
- Everlink to keep your connection stable.
What I liked
- Fastest VPN in my tests at 96% speed retention
- Unlimited devices on one plan
- Antivirus, Alert and Alternative ID bundled
- RAM-only servers and a Deloitte-audited no-logs policy
What I didn’t like
- Based in the Netherlands, a Nine Eyes country
- Owned by Nord Security
- Higher renewal price after the first term
Want the full breakdown? Read my Surfshark One review or check the latest Surfshark coupon page.
2. IPVanish: Best for Unlimited Devices and Budget
IPVanish is the VPN I recommend when someone has a house full of devices and a small budget. It covers unlimited devices and starts at $2.19/mo on the 2-year Essential plan.
IPVanish
IPVanish is my pick for big households and tight budgets. It kept 93% of my baseline speed and starts at $2.19/mo, but it is US based and renews at $99.99+ per year.
- Unlimited devices
- 3650+ servers in 150+ locations
- 56000+ shared IPs
- 50Gbps network
- Twice-audited no-logs
- 24/7 live chat
- Unlimited devices
- 93% speed retention
- Twice-audited no-logs
- Live 24/7 chat on every plan
- Great Fire TV and Apple TV apps
- US based (Five Eyes)
- Renewals jump to $99.99+ per year
- No port forwarding
- Only part of the network is RAM-only
IPVanish Pricing and Plans
IPVanish sells three bundles, and the 2-year plans give the best price. Essential is the standalone VPN with Threat Protection, which blocks ads, trackers and malicious sites at the DNS level.
| Plan | 2-year price | Billed for first 24 months | What you get |
|---|---|---|---|
| Essential | $2.19/mo | $52.56 | VPN, Threat Protection and unlimited devices |
| Complete | $2.79/mo | $66.96 | Everything in Essential plus Next Gen Antivirus (desktop only) |
| Advanced | $3.29/mo | $78.96 | Everything in Complete plus extras such as cloud backup and a secure browser |
The deal I tracked today also includes a 3 GB eSIM data gift, and every plan has a 30-day money-back guarantee. The catch is the renewal price, which jumps to $99.99+ per year after the first term.
My advice is simple: buy the 2-year Essential plan, set a calendar reminder, and decide before renewal whether to stay or switch.
IPVanish Servers and Network
IPVanish runs 3650+ servers in 150+ locations, backed by 56000+ shared IPs. It rebuilt its network to 50Gbps, which is why speeds hold up well during busy hours.
That is far fewer servers than Proton VPN, but the footprint covers 150+ locations, so you can still pick a nearby server almost anywhere. Only part of the network runs on RAM-only servers, which is a small step behind Surfshark One and ExpressVPN.
IPVanish Speed and Performance
IPVanish kept 93% of my baseline speed, which is the second best result in this comparison. Pages load quickly, connections are established fast and 4K streams ramp up without buffering.
IPVanish Privacy and Jurisdiction
IPVanish is based in the United States, a Five Eyes country, which is the biggest weakness compared with Proton VPN. The company has a twice-audited no-logs policy, which is the proof I look for.
There is some history to know about. In 2016, under previous ownership, IPVanish handed connection data to US authorities in a criminal case, which contradicted its no-logs marketing at the time. The service has changed hands since and has been audited twice, so I trust the current version, but privacy purists will still note it.
IPVanish Streaming and Torrenting
For streaming, IPVanish handled US Netflix, Disney+ and Max in my tests. Strict services such as BBC iPlayer and Prime Video were hit or miss depending on the server, so check my guide to the best VPN for Amazon Prime Video if that matters to you.
For torrenting, IPVanish allows P2P traffic and is a long-time favorite of heavy downloaders. The one gap is port forwarding, which it does not offer.
IPVanish Apps and Support
The apps are data heavy, with live speed graphs and server details, which power users enjoy and beginners may find busy. The Fire TV and Apple TV apps are among the best I have used, and if you stream on a TV check my best VPN for Firestick guide.
Support includes live 24/7 chat on every plan, which is better than many rivals. The knowledge base is also extensive.
What I liked
- Unlimited simultaneous devices
- 93% speed retention in my tests
- Twice-audited no-logs policy
- Live 24/7 chat on every plan
- Great Fire TV and Apple TV apps
What I didn’t like
- US based, a Five Eyes country
- Renewals jump to $99.99+ per year
- No port forwarding
- Only part of the network is RAM-only
If the cheap 2-year price and unlimited devices sound right, grab the current deal below.
IPVanish
Essential · 2-year plan
$2.19/mo
$52.56 upfront for 24 months
For more detail, read my IPVanish review or open the IPVanish coupon page for the latest discounts.
Want to compare more VPNs?
See how IPVanish, Proton VPN and Surfshark One stack up against the rest in my ranked list of the best VPNs.
See the best VPNs →3. Proton VPN: Best for Privacy
Proton VPN is the VPN I trust most on pure privacy. It is Swiss based, has open-source apps and offers one of the only free plans I would actually recommend.
Proton VPN
Proton VPN is the better pick of the two for privacy. It is Swiss based, open source and audited with a real free plan, but it caps you at 10 devices and renews at $83.88/yr.
- 10 devices
- 20000+ servers in 140+ countries
- Open-source apps
- Swiss based
- Audited no-logs
- Free plan available
- Open-source apps
- Swiss jurisdiction
- Audited no-logs
- Free plan available
- 20000+ servers in 140+ countries
- 10 device limit
- 92% speed retention vs 93% for IPVanish
- Renews at $83.88/yr
- Costs more than IPVanish at the 2-year price
Proton VPN Pricing and Plans
Proton VPN has a free plan and two paid tiers. VPN Plus is the standalone VPN, while Proton Unlimited bundles the VPN with the rest of the Proton ecosystem.
| Plan | Price | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| Proton Free | $0 | Unlimited data, 1 device, medium speed and servers in 10 countries picked for you |
| VPN Plus | $9.99 monthly, $3.99/mo for 1 year, $2.99/mo for 2 years | 10 devices, 20000+ servers in 140+ countries, streaming, P2P, NetShield and Secure Core |
| Proton Unlimited | $12.99 monthly, $7.99/mo for 2 years | VPN Plus plus Mail, Drive, Pass, Calendar and 500 GB of storage |
The 2-year VPN Plus plan costs $71.76 for the first 24 months and then renews at $83.88 per year. That renewal is noticeably lower than IPVanish at $99.99+ per year, so Proton VPN is the cheaper option once the intro deal ends.
All paid plans include a 30-day money-back guarantee, and the free plan lets you test the apps with no payment details.
Proton VPN Servers and Network
Proton VPN operates 20000+ servers in 140+ countries, one of the biggest networks in the industry. That scale means more locations, fewer crowded servers and a better chance of finding an IP that works for streaming.
For hard-to-reach countries, Smart Routing gives you an IP from the location you want while routing traffic through a safer nearby country. Secure Core servers are owned and provisioned by Proton in hardened facilities.
Proton VPN Security and Privacy
Proton VPN is based in Switzerland, outside the Five Eyes and other major surveillance alliances. Its apps are open source, and the no-logs policy has been audited, so anyone can check the claims.
The security toolkit goes further than IPVanish. These are the features I use most:
- Secure Core: routes your traffic through a hardened first server before the exit server.
- Stealth protocol: helps you get past censorship and deep packet inspection.
- NetShield: blocks ads, trackers and malware at the DNS level.
- Tor over VPN: reaches onion sites from a standard browser.
You can also sign up with minimal personal information and pay with Bitcoin or cash, which most VPNs do not allow.
Proton VPN Speed and Performance
Proton VPN kept 92% of my baseline speed, just one point behind IPVanish. Long-distance connections held up well, and I never had a speed problem that made me switch servers.
Proton VPN Streaming and Torrenting
On the paid plan, Proton VPN unlocked US Netflix, BBC iPlayer and Prime Video in my tests, and it handled 4K streams without buffering. The free plan does not support streaming, so you need VPN Plus for that.
For torrenting, P2P runs on optimized servers marked in the app, and Proton VPN supports port forwarding. That is a real advantage over IPVanish if you seed a lot of torrents.
Proton VPN Apps and Support
The desktop app centers on an interactive world map, and the mobile apps share the same clean design. Linux users get a full graphical app, which is rare.
Paid users get live chat and priority support, and free users rely on email tickets that can take a day to answer. You can connect 10 devices at once, which is enough for most people but less than IPVanish.
What I liked
- Swiss jurisdiction outside the Five Eyes
- Open-source apps and an audited no-logs policy
- Free plan with unlimited data
- 20000+ servers in 140+ countries
- Secure Core, Stealth and port forwarding
What I didn’t like
- Limited to 10 devices
- Slightly slower than IPVanish at 92% retention
- Costs more than IPVanish at the 2-year price
- Renews at $83.88 per year
If privacy is your priority, the 2-year deal is the best way to lock in the lowest price.
Proton VPN
Plus · 2-year plan
$2.99/mo
$71.76 upfront for 24 months
Learn more in my Proton VPN review or see the latest discounts on the Proton VPN coupon page.
Proton VPN vs IPVanish: Category Winners
Here is who wins each category when I put the two side by side. I keep each verdict short so you can jump straight to what matters to you.
Price and Value
IPVanish wins the intro price at $2.19/mo versus $2.99/mo for Proton VPN. Proton VPN wins on renewal at $83.88 per year versus $99.99+ per year, so the long-term gap is smaller than it looks.
Speed
IPVanish wins by a single point, 93% versus 92%. In real use this is a tie.
Privacy and Jurisdiction
Proton VPN wins clearly. It is Swiss based with open-source apps and an audited no-logs policy, while IPVanish is in the United States and carries the 2016 history.
Server Network
Proton VPN wins with 20000+ servers in 140+ countries against 3650+ servers in 150+ locations. IPVanish does have more locations, but Proton has far more IPs to spread the load.
Streaming
Proton VPN is the safer choice on the paid plan, especially for strict libraries like BBC iPlayer. IPVanish works well for US services, but it was less consistent on UK platforms in my tests.
Torrenting
It depends on your setup. Proton VPN offers port forwarding, while IPVanish has no port forwarding but allows P2P and has unlimited devices for a home media server.
Devices
IPVanish wins with unlimited simultaneous devices. Proton VPN allows 10, which is plenty for most households.
Support
IPVanish has live 24/7 chat on every plan. Proton VPN has live chat for paid users, but free users wait for email replies.
Surfshark One vs IPVanish vs Proton VPN
If you are torn between these two, here is the shortcut: Surfshark One matches IPVanish on unlimited devices and beats both on speed. It also adds a security bundle with Antivirus, Alert and Alternative ID that neither rival offers in a single VPN plan.
The trade-off is jurisdiction and ownership. Surfshark One is Netherlands based and owned by Nord Security, so Proton VPN still has the privacy edge on paper.
Surfshark One
One · 3 extra months
$2.49/mo
My #1 VPN Pick$67.23 upfront for 27 months
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Proton VPN better than IPVanish?
Proton VPN is better for privacy, thanks to its Swiss base, open-source apps and free plan. IPVanish is better for price, unlimited devices and a slight speed edge.
Which is faster, Proton VPN or IPVanish?
IPVanish kept 93% of my baseline speed and Proton VPN kept 92%, so they are effectively tied. Surfshark One was faster than both at 96%.
Which is cheaper, IPVanish or Proton VPN?
IPVanish is cheaper at $2.19/mo on the 2-year Essential plan, compared with $2.99/mo for Proton VPN Plus. Proton VPN is cheaper to renew at $83.88 per year versus $99.99+ per year for IPVanish.
Does IPVanish keep logs?
IPVanish has a no-logs policy that has been audited twice. It did hand over data in 2016 under previous ownership, which is why I judge the current service by its recent audits.
Does Proton VPN have a free plan?
Yes. Proton Free has unlimited data and supports 1 device at medium speed, with servers in 10 countries picked for you. It does not support streaming or P2P.
How many devices can I connect?
IPVanish allows unlimited simultaneous devices on every plan. Proton VPN allows 10 devices on its paid plans and 1 on the free plan.
Which is better for streaming?
Proton VPN on the paid plan is the more consistent streaming VPN in my tests, including for BBC iPlayer. IPVanish works well for US Netflix, Disney+ and Max.
Which is better for torrenting?
Both support P2P, and the better pick depends on your setup. Proton VPN offers port forwarding, while IPVanish gives you unlimited devices and no port forwarding.
Is there a better VPN than both?
In my testing, Surfshark One beats both at 96% speed retention, unlimited devices and a full security bundle from $2.49/mo on the 2-year plan. It is my top pick overall.
Do IPVanish and Proton VPN offer refunds?
Yes. Both offer a 30-day money-back guarantee on paid plans, so you can test them risk free.
Final Verdict: Proton VPN vs IPVanish
If I had to split these two, I would pick IPVanish for value and Proton VPN for privacy. IPVanish is cheaper, covers unlimited devices and was a hair faster, while Proton VPN has the stronger jurisdiction, open-source apps and a free plan.
But if you want one VPN that wins on speed, devices and extras at once, I would skip both and buy Surfshark One.
Choose IPVanish if:
- You have lots of devices and want unlimited connections.
- You want the lowest 2-year price at $2.19/mo.
- You use Fire TV or Apple TV a lot.
- You want live 24/7 chat on every plan.
Choose Proton VPN if:
- Privacy and jurisdiction matter most to you.
- You want open-source apps and an audited no-logs policy.
- You want a free plan or port forwarding.
- You need Secure Core or Stealth to stay safe in restrictive regions.
Choose Surfshark One if:
- You want the fastest VPN I have tested.
- You want unlimited devices plus Antivirus, Alert and Alternative ID.
- You want the best overall bundle from $2.49/mo.
Whichever you pick, use the 30-day money-back guarantee to test it on your own connection before you commit.
Surfshark One
The fastest VPN in my tests with unlimited devices and a full security bundle.
- Unlimited devices
- 4500+ servers in 100+ countries
- Antivirus
- Alert
- Alternative ID
- RAM-only servers






